Skip to contentContribute to ReadWriteThink / RSS / FAQs / Site Demonstrations / Contact Us / About Us

 

 

Contribute to ReadWriteThink

ReadWriteThink couldn't publish all of this great content without literacy experts to write and review for us. If you've got lessons plans, activities, or other ideas you'd like to contribute, we'd love to hear from you.

More

 

Professional Development

Find the latest in professional publications, learn new techniques and strategies, and find out how you can connect with other literacy professionals.

More

 

Reading & Language Arts Community

Did You Know?

Your students can save their work with Student Interactives.

More more

HomeClassroom ResourcesLesson Plans

Lesson Plan

Blending Fiction and Nonfiction to Improve Comprehension and Writing Skills

E-mail / Share / Print This Page / Print All Materials (Note: Handouts must be printed separately)

 
Grades 3 – 5
Lesson Plan Type Standard Lesson
Estimated Time Five 60- to 90-minute sessions
Lesson Author

Stephanie Affinito

Stephanie Affinito

Queensbury, New York

Publisher

International Reading Association

 

Student Objectives

Instruction and Activities

Session 1: Reading the fiction text

Session 2: Reading the nonfiction text

Session 3: Discussing the elements of fiction and nonfiction

Session 4: Creative writing

Session 5: Sharing

Student Assessment/Reflections

 

STUDENT OBJECTIVES

Students will

  • Use fiction to begin discussion of a content area topic and to generate questions about the topic

  • Use nonfiction to answer the questions they have about the content area subject

  • Conduct Internet research to further explore the subject and to resolve any questions left unanswered by the nonfiction text

  • Demonstrate their knowledge on the subject and an understanding of the basic elements of fiction and nonfiction:

–By contributing to the creation of a class chart


–By writing an original piece that features both narrative and expository elements

back to top

 

Instruction and Activities

The following outline is approximate. You may need to adjust the number of days depending on the length of texts and how much in-class time you can devote to Internet use. Additional time may also be needed to allow for student writing. Depending on the characteristics of your classroom and the abilities of your students, this writing time will vary.

back to top

 

Session 1: Reading the fiction text

1. Using the Know-What-Learn (K-W-L) method, begin class with a discussion of what the students already know about the topic and generate a list on the board or projector.

[Teacher's note: Use of the K-W-L method is explained in the article cited in the From Theory to Practice section of this lesson. The article also discusses several other strategies that work well with paired texts (i.e., Venn diagramming, directed reading-thinking activity, webbing, and activating prior knowledge). You might use any of these strategies as a substitute or supplement in this lesson.]

2. Ask students what questions they have about the topic? What would they like to learn? List students' ideas and questions in a separate column.

3. Depending on grade level and text availability, read the fiction text aloud or have your students read the text silently. If you are reading aloud, stop along the way to fill in a third column of new facts and information that address the questions asked in the second column. If the students have finished reading silently, generate the third column as a class.

4. Are there any questions in the second column still unanswered? In addition, ask students if they have any new questions to add to the list. At this stage, there should still be a lot left to discover. Explain that fiction is enjoyable, but it may not be the best source for gathering factual information. Let them know that in the next class session they will be turning to a nonfiction text to further explore the topic.

back to top

 

Session 2: Reading the nonfiction text

1. Review the second column generated by the class in the first session. Is there anything else that can be added to the want-to-learn list before going forward?

2. Depending on grade level and text availability, read the nonfiction text aloud or have your students read the text silently. Add to the third column as you did during the previous session.

3. Again, review the second column. Some unanswered questions are likely to still be on the list. If all the questions have been answered, ask the students if reading the nonfiction text has generated yet more questions. Continue to expand on the second column accordingly.

4. Explain that whereas nonfiction is often better than fiction in answering questions about a topic, not all questions will be answered by one nonfiction text. Provide content materials and Internet access for students to explore other nonfiction sources about the topic. Have them take notes as they find new facts and information to add to the K-W-L chart.

5. Have students report back as a class what additional information they have found to complete the third column.

back to top

 

Session 3: Discussing the elements of fiction and nonfiction

1. In a whole-class discussion, chart the genre elements of fiction and nonfiction, having students cite examples from the texts and the Internet. Chart responses so that fiction elements are on one side and nonfiction elements are on the opposite side, leaving space in the middle for a chart that will blend elements from both sides. (See Sample Genre Chart as a guide.)

2. Prompt students about the possibility of texts having both narrative and expository elements. Ask for textual examples from the paired set and, as a class, discuss the types of writing that blend fiction and nonfiction elements: Are they familiar with realistic fiction? The Magic School Bus series? Can a letter be both narrative and expository? A diary? A comic strip?

3. Return to the empty column between the fiction and nonfiction charts. What elements, fiction and nonfiction, can be found in the types of texts just discussed? Chart these elements in the middle column.

4. Explain to students that their task will be to create an imaginative work (narrative) that includes facts about the given topic (expository), blending the genre elements of fiction and nonfiction as you have just done in the middle column. Distribute the criteria checklist (or a modified version of your own) to students, so that they are fully aware of what is expected in the final product.

5. Encourage students to choose the type of writing piece they will create and later share. Be sure and let students know what form this sharing will take (several suggestions are given in Session 5) and how this portion of the lesson will be assessed.

Provide a brief time for students to talk out their ideas and share story starters and elements of their writing with the class or with partners. Share possible ideas to get them started.

back to top

 

Session 4: Creative writing

1. Provide time for students to independently complete their writing pieces, offering support and guidance throughout the process.

2. Encourage students who are writing in one of the following applicable formats to create a final product using an interactive from this website:

3. If more time is needed, have students complete their writing as a homework assignment.

back to top

 

Session 5: Sharing

For this part of the lesson, a variety of sharing techniques could be used, such as whole-class presentations, small-group presentations, or partner reads. Other real-life applications could include sharing in the school newspaper, with a younger class, at an author's share or authors' tea, with family members, or in a library display.

The timeframe is also flexible, not necessarily limited to one day. For example, sharing could be worked in throughout the school day, as in a daily morning activity.

back to top

 

STUDENT ASSESSMENT/REFLECTIONS

  • Observation, anecdotal notes based on class discussions, and student handouts can be used to assess:
  • How well students use the fiction text to generate ideas and questions about the subject

  • How well students approach the nonfiction text as a means of gaining knowledge on the subject

  • How well students use the Internet as a nonfiction source to answer their questions

    • Note students' contribution to and understanding of the class-generated K-W-L and genre charts.

    • Evaluate the writing assignment based on how well students blend elements of the two genres and demonstrate knowledge gained on the subject. (The criteria checklist can aid in this assessment.)

    • If sharing takes some form of oral presentation, your classroom or state standards rubric may be applied here.

    back to top