|
|
|
|
| Overview |
At first glance, The Simpsons may look like a simple cartoon, but look
more closely and you’ll find a nearly inexhaustible collection of resources
for exploring satire in the classroom. In this lesson students identify the techniques
of satire (exaggeration, incongruity, reversal, and parody) through an analysis
of visual examples of the television show, The Simpsons, and from the
show’s Web site.
|
| From Theory to Practice |
Popular culture, in the form of the episodes from The Simpsons, provide
an introduction to and extended exploration of the literary techniques that
are commonly used in satire. This pairing of popular culture with traditional
literary instruction provides what Meg Callahan and Bronwen E. Low call “a
meeting place where students and teachers can share their expertise” (52).
Through their extensive research with secondary students, Callahan and Low concluded
that “many
students identified the use of popular culture in the classroom as a catalyst
for complex thinking” (57).
Callahan and Low identify popular culture as “a site where students can
experience competence at the same time that the teachers provide appropriate
challenges through careful support, reframing, and questioning” (57).
Further Reading
Callahan, Meg, and Bronwen E. Low. “At
the Crossroads of Expertise: The Risky Business of Teaching Popular Culture.” English Journal 93.3
(January 2004): 52-57.
|
| Student Objectives |
Students will
- identify the four techniques of satire in a satirical work.
- explain how the
four techniques of satire contribute to the comment or criticism being made
by a satirical work.
- analyze a satirical work to determine the comment or criticism being made
about the subject it is ridiculing.
- use visual literacy skills to analyze,
interpret, and explain non-print media.
|
| Instructional Plan |
Resources
Preparation
- To review the techniques of satire, you can complete Exploring
Satire with
Shrek before beginning this more detailed exploration of
satire.
- Make an overhead or copies of the Opening Segment from The Simpsons,
or copy the info to a sheet of chart paper. You might also write the list on
the board while students watch the opening segment in Session One.
- Make copies of additional handouts, or make overheads that students can refer
to as they work on these sessions.
- If possible, obtain headphones for students to use during Session Two. Because
students will be exploring a Web site with many audio features, the classroom
will quickly be filled with competing audio clips. Headphones will help you
control the room and keep students focused.
- This lesson focuses on the “Two Cars in Every Garage and Three Eyes
on Every Fish” episode of The Simpsons; however the activity works
well with many other episodes. Additional suggestions are included.
- Test the Interactive
Character Profiles from The
Simpsons Official Web Site on
your computers to familiarize yourself with the tools and ensure that you have
the Flash plug-in installed. You can download the plug-in
from the technical support page.
Instruction and Activities
Session One:
Analyzing the Title and Opening Sequence of The Simpsons
- Before class begins, cue the the opening credits of the “Two Cars in
Every Garage and Three Eyes on Every Fish” from The Simpsons.
- Explain that you are going to show a video clip and ask students to compare
what they see in the clip with life in a typical family.
- Ask students to respond in their reader response notebooks or journals to
the following question to gather their ideas before they see the clip: “Brainstorm
a list of things that happened yesterday after school.”
- Emphasize that
students need only gather a jotted list, rather than fully detailed descriptions.
Provide a few examples from your own day (e.g., left school, went to the
gym, picked up kids).
- While students work, circulate among the class, monitoring student work.
If you notice students deeply involved in specifics, redirect them toward a
simpler list of activities.
- Once students have written their lists, set up the clip by explaining that
you will show the opening sequence from The
Simpsons and ask them to pay attention to the things that happen to this
family during the sequence.
- Show the opening segment of The Simpsons and pass out or post
the following
parts of the opening segment:
- Bart writing on the blackboard
- Bart on his skateboard
- Homer leaving and driving home from work
- Marge at the supermarket checkout
- Lisa playing the saxophone
- The family racing for the couch in front of the television
- Ask students to compare the events in the opening sequence to their
own lists of after-school activities, inviting conjecture on why the cartoon
begins with these events rather than others that might be chosen. If students
identify satire as a purpose, encourage that line of discovery.
- If students have not already suggested it, explain that The Simpsons is
frequently described as a highly satirical program.
- Review the definition
of satire:
A work that ridicules its subject through the use of
techniques such as exaggeration, reversal, incongruity, and/or parody
in order to make a comment or criticism about it.
- Ask students to identify the subtle or secondary meaning of the show’s
title, The
Simpsons. Technically, the etymology for the name is “son
of Sim,” which is short for Simon. The possible pun, however, is the
play on the word simple.
- Revisit the parts of the opening segment and consider what they may
be satirizing. Below are
examples of how students might respond to the second question:
- Bart writing on the blackboard: Public education
- Bart on his skateboard: The riddles of childhood
- Homer leaving and driving home from work: Plight of the working man
- Marge at the supermarket checkout: Consumerism (Note: Maggie costs $847.63)
- Lisa playing the saxophone: Restrictions of public education and free thought
- The family racing for the couch in front of the television: Impact of television
on the modern family
- Encourage students to share specific examples from different episodes that
address each of the areas that are addressed in the opening segment.
- Before concluding the session, identify the students who are not familiar
with the show and encourage them to view an episode of the show before the
next session. All students can be encouraged to watch the cartoon for homework;
however, you may want to prepare a note for families, explaining that students
are using the cartoon to explore satirical techniques in class.
Session Two: Analyzing Characters from The Simpsons
- Explain that during this session of the class, students will explore information
about characters from The Simpsons online and analyze the details for satirical
techniques.
- Pass out the Analyzing Characters from The Simpsons sheet,
which includes instructions and a list of characters.
- Choose one character from the list to analyze as a class, in order to demonstrate
the process. Since you'll do this character as a class, ask students to remove
that character from the list of choices. Sample analysis responses are available
for several characters.
- Using an LCD Projector, visit the Interactive
Character Profiles on The Simpsons Web Site.
- Locate the profile for the character you’ve chosen in the filing cabinet.
- Explore the information for the character, being sure to talk about everything
that is included. Each file includes
a
biography
with
background
information,
pictures of the character, and other related information. Pages for
human characters also include quotations from the character. Find the “Click
It!” link(s) on
the right side of the folder as well.
- As you work through the information for the character, ask students to look
for and identify satirical details that reveal the comment or criticism of
society that the cartoon is making
through the character.
- Encourage students to think-aloud about the reasons for the kinds of information
that are included. Ask leading questions such as “Why do you think they
included this quotation for this character?” or “Why do you think
this picture is included instead of another one?”
- Record
observations the character the class is exploring on the board or on chart
paper. To simplify the process of exploring the profile and recording the information,
ask a student volunteer to record information while you guide the exploration
of the site.
- Reinforce the labeling of satirical techniques by extending students’ observations.
For instance, if a student notices that something is exaggerated, build on
the observation by asking students to identify other examples of exaggeration
that are used in the character’s profile and personality.
- Once you’ve explore the profile for the character, review the information
that has been recorded and make any additions or corrections.
- In light of all the satirical information that you've gathered from the character’s
profile, ask students to identify the comment or criticism about society that
the show is making through the character.
- Answer any questions that students have about the sample character you’ve
explored then pass out the Character Analysis Chart that students will use
to record their findings on the characters that they choose from the Analyzing
Characters from The Simpsons sheet.
- Encourage students to use headphones, if available, to help control the noise
level of the class.
- Remind them that they need to explore profiles for at least six characters
during the remainder of the session.
- Acknowledge that it will be easy for students
to be distracted by the fun of the site, so you’ll call out reminders
every five minutes to help
them pace their work. If they change to a new character every five minutes,
they should be able to complete their analysis before the session ends.
- Circulate through the classroom while students work. Pay attention to students’ progress
on the Character Analysis Charts to notice any students who fall behind
and need to catch up in order to finish by the end of the session.
- Collect completed Character Analysis Charts at the end of the session
and review them for evidence of students’ understanding of the techniques
of satire.
Session Three: Analyzing an Episode of The Simpsons
- Before class begins, cue the “Two Cars
in Every Garage and Three Eyes on Every Fish”episode of The
Simpsons.
- Explain that during this session of the class, students will analyze an
entire episode of The
Simpsons for satirical techniques and commentary.
- Share the summary
of the episode
with the class.
- Ask students to predict the themes that will be the subject of satire
in the episode. Students should easily be able to identify nuclear power
(or environmental issues) and political campaigns, but may come up with additional
themes.
- Note the themes on the
board or on chart paper.
- Pass out the Episode Analysis Chart and ask students to choose
two satirical themes to focus on while watching the episode. Have them write
their choices at the top of the columns
- Ask students to look for satirical
techniques in the episode that relate to the
themes
they
have
identified.
They should find at least three examples for each theme. Refer to the Sample
Responses handout for examples of how students might respond to this assignment.
- Show the episode of the show, while students take notes on the satirical
techniques that are employed.
- After the episode concludes, arrange the class into small groups to
discuss their observations and draw conclusions about the comment or criticism
made about the themes that are satirized.
- Once groups have drawn their conclusions, bring the class together and
invite groups to share their examples and observations. Reinforce the labeling
of satirical techniques and use of literary terminology.
- Collect completed Episode Analysis Charts at the end of the session
and review them for evidence of students’ understanding of the techniques
of satire.
Extensions
- Ask students to find an example of a work in print media or on the Internet
that uses the techniques of satire to make a comment or criticism about a
subject from contemporary society. To complete this assignment students should
include the following in writing: title of the work and bibliographic information,
a short summary of the work (or a copy of the work), two examples of satirical
techniques in the work, and the comment or criticism being made about a subject
in contemporary society. One of the best sources for students to use
when completing this assignment is the satirical newspaper, The
Onion.
For an example of political satire, share the short cartoon, “This
Land Is Your Land”. This film takes a satirical look at the campaigns
of John Kerry and George W. Bush during the 2004 Presidential election. Be
sure to review sites that you suggest to students to ensure that they are
appropriate for your classroom and community. Begin the assignment by exploring
a
list of popular satire that students can use as resources for their
selection.
- Ask students to write an essay that explains how individual techniques
of satire are used in an episode of The Simpsons to make a comment
about a subject from contemporary society. The essay should include a summary
of the episode, an explanation of the main comment or criticism the episode
is making, and identify three different examples
of satirical elements used in the episode. For each example, the paper should
describe the example in concrete detail, explain what the subject, idea, or issue
was like before it was satirized, explain how a satirical technique (such as
exaggeration) is used in the example, and explain how the example contributed
to the main comment or criticism about contemporary society. Share the list
of
additional episodes as possible starting places for this activity.
- Ask students to create an original piece of writing that uses the techniques
of satire to make a comment or criticism about an issue in contemporary society.
The written piece must be original and include at least three different
types of satirical techniques. Responses can include a parody of a newspaper
reporting a news event that might appear in The
Onion or on The Daily Show, a parody of a popular song that
might be sung by someone such as “Weird Al" Yankovic.
Web Resources
- The Simpsons Official Web Site
http://www.thesimpsons.com/
- The official Web site
for The Simpsons includes details on characters and past episodes.
It’s a good place to start if you are unfamiliar with the show and
looking for a well-organized introduction. The site requires
the Flash Plug-in.
- The Simpsons Archive
http://www.snpp.com/
- This site includes guides to the episodes and other information related
to the show. The site includes lists of the couch
gags from the opening sequence,
the chalkboard
sentences from the opening sequence, and the titles
of the “Itchy
and Scratchy” segments on the show.
- Wikipedia Entry on The Simpsons
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Simpsons
- This online encyclopedia entry provides an extensive overview of the cartoon
series, including details on the characters, setting, and trivia.
|
| Student Assessment/Reflections |
Informal assessment works best for this activity. As students work,
circulate among students, observing
students’ analytical process and their understanding of satirical techniques.
Provide support and feedback as you move through the room. To guide more formal
feedback on the activities, use the Character
Analysis Rubric and the Episode Analysis Rubric.
|
1 - Students read a wide range of print and nonprint texts to build an understanding of texts, of themselves, and of the cultures of the United States and the world; to acquire new information; to respond to the needs and demands of society and the workplace; and for personal fulfillment. Among these texts are fiction and nonfiction, classic and contemporary works.
3 - Students apply a wide range of strategies to comprehend, interpret, evaluate, and appreciate texts. They draw on their prior experience, their interactions with other readers and writers, their knowledge of word meaning and of other texts, their word identification strategies, and their understanding of textual features (e.g., sound-letter correspondence, sentence structure, context, graphics).
6 - Students apply knowledge of language structure, language conventions (e.g., spelling and punctuation), media techniques, figurative language, and genre to create, critique, and discuss print and nonprint texts.
8 - Students use a variety of technological and information resources (e.g., libraries, databases, computer networks, video) to gather and synthesize information and to create and communicate knowledge.
11 - Students participate as knowledgeable, reflective, creative, and critical members of a variety of literacy communities.
12 - Students use spoken, written, and visual language to accomplish their own purposes (e.g., for learning, enjoyment, persuasion, and the exchange of information).
|
|
|