Standard Lesson

Create a Comic Book Vignette of Immigration to the US

Grades:
6–12
Lesson Plan Type:
Standard Lesson
Estimated Time:
Four to nine (4–9) 45-minute class sessions
Author:
Jeff Gentile
Publisher:
NCTE
  • Preview
  • |
  • Resources & Preparation
  • |
  • Instructional Plan
  • |
  • Related Resources
  • |
  • Standards

Overview

Through a series of lessons, students will analytically read Great Immigrants, Great Americans and then research specific waves of immigration to the United States. Students will then craft historical expository vignettes in comic-book format.

Students often read, watch, or hear individual stories of immigrants to this country and learn of their experiences, struggles, and achievements. But a broader understanding is often still lacking as to what pushes people away from their homes and homeland and what draws them to the United States. With this activity, students will focus more on the global or national dynamics that push and pull people from one place to another. This is also very much an interdisciplinary project between social studies and English language arts.

Featured Resources

Materials and Technology

  • Lined paper and copy paper 
  • 11"×17" copy paper (optional)
  • #2 lead pencils for writing and drafting comic book format panels and images
  • Color pencils or gel pens
  • Comic Panel Page template designs (blank examples)
  • Optional: Fine-tipped pens for inking/finalizing comic format

Printouts

Comic Book Page templates (for design ideas)

Page of IMMIGRATION WAVES/eras as typically divided in history books (for research)

Websites

A free online comic book commissioned by the Carnegie Corporation of New York featuring more than a dozen naturalized citizens whose contributions and actions have enhanced and strengthened American society and democracy.

United Through Reading article that includes multiple theoretical and practical uses of graphic novels for literacy. Includes sources and examples for how graphic novels enhance comprehension and vocabulary, bridge reading gaps, promote engagement, enhance curriculum, and more.

Preparation

  1. Decide how to provide informational material on immigration to students (e.g., textbooks, online sources, free research strategies, YouTube videos, etc.).
  2. Decide if this is an assignment used as a complement to a study of individual immigrant stories or if it is a stand-alone subject assignment.
  3. Decide how many research topics (waves) will be included based on where you are in your own curriculum or story or based on the demographics of your classroom populations.
  4. Have comic panel templates ready. 
  5. Create a template or rough draft of your own, even if it’s just text saying where images or text should go.
  6. Have resources/links ready, unless students are expected to freely research topics on their own.

Student Objectives

Students will:

  • read and analyze biographical comic narratives to identify key events, character traits, and contributions of immigrants to U.S. history.
    Reading & Comprehension (RI.1, RI.3)
  • comprehend and interpret the experiences of immigrants through the lens of social, cultural, and historical contexts.
    Reading & Comprehension (RI.2, RH.2)
  • conduct research on a selected naturalized U.S. citizen to gather biographical details including birthplace, immigration experience, challenges, achievements, and societal contributions.
    Research & Inquiry (W.7, RH.7)
  • synthesize information from multiple sources to create a coherent narrative of an immigrant’s life and legacy.
     Research & Inquiry (W.8, RH.9)
  • compose an “I Am” poem from the perspective of a selected immigrant, using specific details to convey personal history, motivations, challenges, and accomplishments.
    Writing & Composition (W.3, W.4)
  • apply knowledge of poetic structure and figurative language to develop voice and perspective in the poem.
    Writing & Composition (L.5, W.3.b)
  • analyze examples of comics and sequential art to understand panel layout, pacing, and visual storytelling techniques.
    Media Literacy & Visual Composition (RL.7, RI.7)
  • translate written text into a visual format by designing and illustrating a 1–2 page comic that represents the “I Am” poem, applying conventions of comic design.
    Media Literacy & Visual Composition (SL.5, W.6)
  • demonstrate creative expression through the integration of text and images to narrate a biographical story in comic form.
     Creative Expression & Design (W.4, SL.5)
  • utilize drafting, revising, and inking techniques to produce a polished illustrated product.
    Creative Expression & Design (W.5)
  • adjust language, style, and visual choices to effectively communicate to a variety of audiences through multimodal formats.
    Language & Communication (W.4, L.3)

Session Introduction and Activities

Session Introduction and Activities

I. Review or Present Essential Questions

(1 session)

  1. What are the different waves of immigration to the United States and what are the characteristics of a “wave” of immigration? (See section II below for more information.)
  2. Why have people immigrated to the United States? What are the “pushes” and “pulls” of these waves of immigration? What are the typical or common reasons that people are “pushed” from their homeland or “pulled” to the United States (motivations)?
  3. What are the typical challenges people experience leaving their home and home country and emigrating to the United States? What are the common or unique experiences for immigrants leaving their home?
  4. How do immigrants typically adapt to their new home? How do they survive and assimilate into a new culture, and in what ways are they able to maintain their own racial or ethnic culture?

 

II. Research and Take Notes on a Specific Wave of Immigration 

(1–2 sessions; teachers should adjust questions as needed)

  1. Research and take notes on a particular group’s major “wave” of immigration to the United States. Focus on events or pressures or causes that make so many people leave their homeland. What is happening? Why? Who or what is involved in these causes? Why are these things happening?  
  2. How many people leave over time? How big is this “wave?”  Who, exactly, is leaving? What are the demographics?
  3. How do people leave? By what routes or means? What is this trip like and how long can it take? What do these immigrants typically experience on this journey?
  4. How are they received in the United States? What are the challenges, opportunities, struggles? How do these newcomers adapt and thrive?

 

Typical or traditional “waves” of immigration to the United States from colonial times through today (not all inclusive):

  1. 1600s: European exploration and settlements (Spain, England, France, Dutch Netherlands) (These can all be broken down into individual sections, per teacher instructions)
  2. 1600s–1800s: African forced migration
  3. 1820s: Continued European immigration (dominated by German and Irish Catholics, British)
  4. 1840s: Irish immigration (caused by the Great Potato Famine, Transcontinental Railroad)
  5. 1840s: Chinese immigration (caused by the Gold Rush, Transcontinental Railroad)
  6. 1880s: Southern and Eastern European immigration waves (Greece, Poland, Russia, Asia) (due to work and religious persecution, such as Russian Pogroms)
  7. 1890s Japanese (Issei) immigration (into the Hawaii islands then to the Pacific Northwest)
  8. 1890s–present: Cuban immigration (although there have been various waves of Cuban migration)
  9. 1942–1964: Mexican immigration (due to the Bracero Program specifically)
  10. 1960s: Jamaican immigration (which also dated to post-Panama Canal era)
  11. 1975–current: Post-Vietnam War Vietnamese immigration
  12. 1990s: Somali immigration (due to conflict and related issues like famine, floods, drought, etc.)
  13. 2010: Haitian immigration (due to earthquake and political instability, but this also dates as far back as the 1950s)

Note: Depending on the makeup of your class, there are many other more specific immigration waves of various sizes from a number of different countries, including Haiti, Jamaica, all South and Middle American countries, India, Pakistan, and other places. Add these to your list of options as you put the assignment together for your students.

 

III. Create a Brief 1–2 Page “Expository Essay” in Comic Book Format, Combining Sequential Art and Text

(2–4 sessions)

  1. Review examples of page designs and panel ideas in comic book narrative form.
  2. Start to think of images to combine or draw with expository text using comic panel templates, referring to examples for ideas.
  3. Finalize and polish 1–2 page illustrated versions of a background or explanation of a particular immigration wave with dark outlines and color, if desired. (Can use 11"×17" copy paper to keep pages together.)
  4. Share in groups, compile into an anthology collection comic book, or post on walls.

Note: For some students, an accommodation can include creating the page and panel design with indications of where text should go and what could be drawn in the panel (just like some comic book writers who create a script for the artist or comic story do).
 

Extensions

Some Additional Online Accessible Examples of Page Designs that Could Be Used to Inspire, Mentor, or Guide Students

Chester Crab Comics page on “How Did People Rush To Gold?” 

One way to design a comic page with text and images in panel format on a general topic of human movement that wouldn’t be one of the topics students would be researching.

Chester Crab Comics page on “Where Did Colonists Stop Burgoyne?”

Take notes of images like maps and geography and other items that might be easy to draw to illustrate the content.

Grant Snyder’s Incidental Comics

Examples of narrative comic pages/poetry/sequential art; not really expository historical text pages but still show interesting and possible page/panel designs.

Creating a Comic: The Journey (The Tap)

Not a history comic per se but gives students a sense of how easy stick figures and some art can be to include to show narrative structure.

Mark Trail (Sunday Comic Strip) Water Fowl Migration 

A possible mentor Sunday comic strip that can help guide students on sequential narrative from panel to panel. Not migration per se, but all of Mark Trail’s strips are good examples of concise, informative sequential facts that are enhanced by the images included in each panel.

From Theory to Practice

McCloud, S. (1994). Understanding Comics: The Invisible Art. Harper Collins.

National Council of Teachers of English. (1975). Resolution on Promoting Media Literacy. Web. http://www.ncte.org/positions/statements/promotingmedialit

Norton, B. (2003). The motivating power of comic books: Insight from Archie comic readers. The Reading Teacher, 57(2), 140–147. 

Versaci, R. (2001). How comic books can change the way our students see literature: One teacher’s perspective. English Journal, 91(2), 61–67.

Standards

A complete listing of the standards can be found here.

1. Students read a wide range of print and nonprint texts to build an understanding of texts, of themselves, and of the cultures of the United States and the world; to acquire new information; to respond to the needs and demands of society and the workplace; and for personal fulfillment. Among these texts are fiction and nonfiction, classic and contemporary works.

4. Students adjust their use of spoken, written, and visual language (e.g., conventions, style, vocabulary) to communicate effectively with a variety of audiences and for different purposes.

6. Students apply knowledge of language structure, language conventions (e.g., spelling and punctuation), media techniques, figurative language, and genre to create, critique, and discuss print and nonprint texts.

8. Students use a variety of technological and information resources (e.g., libraries, databases, computer networks, video) to gather and synthesize information and to create and communicate knowledge.

11. Students participate as knowledgeable, reflective, creative, and critical members of a variety of literacy communities.

12. Students use spoken, written, and visual language to accomplish their own purposes (e.g., for learning, enjoyment, persuasion, and the exchange of information).