Skip to main content
ReadWriteThink - Powered by NCTE
  • About
  • Classroom Resources
    • Lesson Plans
    • Teaching Comics
    • Teaching With Primary Resources
    • Calendar
    • Printouts
    • Student Interactives
  • Collections
    • Assessment
    • Authors
    • Booklists
    • Media Literacy
    • Poetry
    • Primary Sources
    • Writing
  • Professional Development
    • Strategy Guides
    • Professional Library
    • Meetings & Events
  • Join NCTE
  • Contact Us
  • About
  • Classroom Resources
    • Lesson Plans
    • Teaching Comics
    • Teaching With Primary Resources
    • Calendar
    • Printouts
    • Student Interactives
  • Collections
    • Assessment
    • Authors
    • Booklists
    • Media Literacy
    • Poetry
    • Primary Sources
    • Writing
  • Professional Development
    • Strategy Guides
    • Professional Library
    • Meetings & Events
  • Join NCTE
  • Contact Us
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest
  • YouTube

Breadcrumb

  1. Home

Type

  • Classroom Resources
  • Professional Development

Learning Objectives

  • collaboration (458)
  • Comprehension (508)
  • critical thinking (649)
  • digital literacy (154)
  • Grammar (57)
  • inquiry / research (350)
  • listening (182)
  • literary analysis (367)
  • Media literacy (205)
  • metacognition (302)
  • multicultural awareness (113)
  • multimodal literacy (260)
  • oral communication (224)
  • phonological awareness (61)
  • print awareness (89)
  • reading fluency (67)
  • reading genres (290)
  • Spelling (51)
  • text structure / story structure (242)
  • Vocabulary (191)
  • writing genres (382)
  • writing process (421)

Topics

  • arts
  • careers
  • community
  • drama
  • ELL
  • Family
  • fiction
  • Mathematics
  • Mobile Learning
  • nonfiction
  • poetry
  • science
  • seasons / holidays
  • social action
  • social studies / history
  • Sports
  • STEM

Amarillo Daily News [Image 8]

Amarillo Daily News [Image 8]
Lesson By
Shona Rose, PhD
Citation

Amarillo Daily News (Amarillo, Tex.), February 4, 1916. 1916. Newspaper. Library of Congress Chronicling America. https://www.loc.gov/item/sn85042551/1916-02-04/ed-1/.

Source Type
Newspapers
Suggested Grade Band: Grade 6, Grade 7, Grade 8
Describe How Students Will Engage with the Source

In 1916, an advertisement for Amarillo National Bank declares “Women have always had their rights at the Amarillo National Bank.” By examining women’s rights timelines, learners will evaluate the advertisement to answer the question: Did women have rights in 1916 at a bank in the Panhandle of Texas? Or were there conditions not noted in the advertisement? How do consumers use historical and actual data to evaluate sources and make decisions about claims of businesses?

Historical/Community Context for the Primary Source

In 1916, women were still denied the right to vote. But this bank in west Texas allowed women the rights to their own personal and household accounts. This advertisement puts this bank at the forefront of the fight for not only the vote but for women’s independence.

 

Instructional Focus Question(s) for Discussion
  1. What does the advertisement reveal about women in a small Texas town?
  2. Would this advertisement be placed in a modern newspaper? Why or why not?
  3. How do we know if the claims in the advertisement are accurate?
Standards Connection (State)
TX
Standards Connections

Texas

 

ELA Standard

6.8E. Multiple genres. listening, speaking, reading, writing, and thinking using multiple texts—genres. The student recognizes and analyzes genre-specific characteristics, structures, and purposes within and across increasingly complex traditional, contemporary, classical, and diverse texts. The student is expected to (8E) analyze characteristics and structures of argumentative texts.

Social Studies Standard

8.29D. Social studies skills. The student applies critical‐thinking skills to organize and use information acquired through established research methodologies from a variety of valid sources, including technology. The student is expected to identify bias and points of view created by the historical context surrounding an event

NCTE Standards 8

Students use a variety of technological and information resources (e.g., libraries, databases, computer networks, video) to gather and synthesize information and to create and communicate knowledge.

 

Instructional Design
  • Using the Observe-Reflect-Question method, learners begin by examining the Amarillo National Bank’s advertisement titled “Women’s Rights” to find the claims and evidence provided in the advertisement. Learners can also compare the claims and structures in the other advertisements on the page. Next, learners note the date of publication.
  • Use these questions to prompt discussion and deeper exploration:
    • How do we know if advertisements are true when we are making purchasing decisions?
    • What are the key components of argumentative texts that consumers should seek to understand?
    • How might the overarching political climate of the local area, state, and nation help a consumer evaluate claims?
  • Learners reflect by testing their knowledge of American history timelines and women’s rights issues. They test their hypotheses by researching multiple sources regarding women’s rights before and after legislation and constitutional amendments.
  • Finally, learners question the statements in the advertisement in comparison with their findings from research. Did women likely have rights in Amarillo? Were there conditions in which women were able to open accounts? What further research should be completed?
Tags:
Evaluating advertisements, Evaluating arguments, Research and inquiry, Observe-Reflect-Question, Primary source analysis, Visual literacy
Alternative or Complementary Primary Sources

Library of Congress. "Women’s Suffrage." Accessed June 2024. https://www.loc.gov/classroom-materials/womens-suffrage/.

Subject/Topic:
Geography, history, social studies, Government, law, politics, Journalism/news, advertising
Is Mosaic Content
On

Tall Tales from Texas

Tall Tales from Texas
Lesson By
Shona Rose, PhD
Citation

Boatright, Mody C. Tall tales from Texas. Dallas: The Southwest Press, ca. 1934. https://www.loc.gov/item/34024636/.

Source Type
Books and Other Printed Texts Manuscripts
Suggested Grade Band: Grade 6, Grade 7, Grade 8
Describe How Students Will Engage with the Source

Using critical inquiry, learners will examine five tales to determine genre characteristics and structures. After examining the fables and drawing conclusions, learners examine the preface and introduction to the source to determine the author’s purpose and message. Learners research values and priorities revealed in the introduction and his “Preface on Authentic Liars” to propose a statement that captures the author’s probable purpose in 1934. Learners may also conduct additional research of Texas in the 1930s for historical context and societal priorities.

Historical/Community Context for the Primary Source

In 1934, citizens of the United States experienced the impact of the Great Depression, and Mody Boatright published Tall Tales from Texas. The text is lighthearted and openly honest about how Texans told stories—or lies, depending on your viewpoint.

 

 

Source: https://www.tshaonline.org/handbook/entries/great-depression

 

Instructional Focus Question(s) for Discussion
  1. What do the tales reveal about attitudes, values, politics, religion, etc.?
  2. When you compare the tales to the preface and the introduction, what insights from the tales are confirmed? What ideas did you adjust with the additional information?
Standards Connection (State)
TX
Standards Connections

Texas

 

ELA Standard

7.5I. Comprehension. monitor comprehension, and make adjustments such as rereading, using background knowledge, asking questions, and annotating when comprehension breaks down.

Social Studies Standard

7.20B. Social studies skills. Analyze information by applying absolute and relative chronology through sequencing, categorizing, identifying cause-and-effect relationships, comparing, contrasting, finding the main idea, summarizing, making generalizations and predictions, and drawing inferences and conclusions.

NCTE Standard 7

Students conduct research on issues and interests by generating ideas and questions, and by posing problems. They gather, evaluate, and synthesize data from a variety of sources (e.g., print and non-print texts, artifacts, people) to communicate their discoveries in ways that suit their purpose and audience.

Instructional Design
  • Observe: Introduce the text, Tales from Texas. Allow learners to select up to five tales and images.
  • Reflect: Learners create a chart of characteristics—characteristics, text structures, etc. Learners compare and contrast their findings with others.
  • Observe: Examine the bibliographic information and citation.
  • Question: What does the time period reveal about the author’s purpose and possible use for this text? What influenced writers at the time of publication? At the time of the original tales? How would the text and images change if set in today’s time period and geographical locations?
  • Reflect: Test ideas by researching more about the 20th century, 1934 in particular, on the following site: https://www.tshaonline.org/handbook/entries/great-depression
  • Question and Reflect: Learners meet for a Socratic seminar after dipping in and out of the materials. Questions include: How do cultural ideas impact what we read and write? Why is it important to examine the time period of a publication to contextualize the author’s approach, methods, and points of view? How does cultural understanding influence deeper comprehension and understanding of authorial intent?
  • Additional Questions: How did the introduction and preface add to the reader’s knowledge and experience with the tales?
Tags:
Author's purpose and craft, Critical inquiry, Observe-Reflect-Question, Primary source analysis, Socratic seminar, Synthesis, Visual literacy
Alternative or Complementary Primary Sources

Cullison, Irene Margaret. Mother Goose finger plays. Illustrated by C. M. Burd. Philadelphia: George W. Jacobs & Co., 1915. https://www.loc.gov/item/19015140/.

Subject/Topic:
American popular culture, Geography, history, social studies
Is Mosaic Content
On

A Modern Day Replica of the “Come and [Take] It” Flag

A Modern Day Replica of the “Come and [Take] It” Flag
Lesson By
Shona Rose, PhD
Citation

Highsmith, Carol M. A modern-day replica of the "Come and Get It" flag in Gonzales, Texas. 2014. Photograph. Library of Congress Prints and Photographs Division. https://www.loc.gov/item/2014632803/.

Source Type
Photographs and Prints
Suggested Grade Band: Grade 9, Grade 10, Grade 11, Grade 12
Describe How Students Will Engage with the Source

Students examine the flag in the image and discuss possible meanings. After a short amount of research and inquiry, learners debate questions such as: Does this flag still represent the same concept from its origin? Do contemporary citizens use the flag to convey an appropriate message?

Historical/Community Context for the Primary Source

A group of Texas women made the “Come and Take It” flag after the Battle of Gonzales, the first battle of the Texas Revolution. Basically, the settlers used the flag to revolt against the Mexican government, refusing to give back the cannon originally provided by the Mexican government to defend themselves against Indian raids.

Source: https://bit.ly/48216os, Source: : https://bit.ly/48216os

Instructional Focus Question(s) for Discussion
  1. Have you seen these flags in the community or news?
  2. Considering the notes provided with the resource, what did the flag originally mean to Texans?
  3. Is the modern use of the flag consistent with its original purpose?
  4. Extension: How are flags and images used to tell important stories?
Standards Connection (State)
TX
Standards Connections

Texas

ELA Standard

E2.10C.Composition. Compose argumentative texts with genre characteristics and craft.

Social Studies Standard

WH.28F. Social studies skills. Formulate and communicate visually, orally, or in writing a claim supported by evidence and reasoning for an intended audience and purpose.

NCTE Standard 7

Students conduct research on issues and interests by generating ideas and questions, and by posing problems. They gather, evaluate, and synthesize data from a variety of sources (e.g., print and non-print texts, artifacts, people) to communicate their discoveries in ways that suit their purpose and audience.

Instructional Design
  • Observe: Display the image of the flag and ask, “Have you seen these flags in the community or news?”
  • Show learners how to read and evaluate sources using advice from the Purdue Online Writing Lab (OWL): https://owl.purdue.edu/owl/research_and_citation/conducting_research/evaluating_sources_of_information/general_guidelines.html
  • Observe: Consider the Notes section of the Library of Congress information for this image. What did the “Come and Take It” flag mean originally?
  • Reflect: Is the image being used in modern times to convey the original message?
  • Question: Examine the Newsweek article https://www.newsweek.com/texas-national-guard-come-take-it-flag-border-1865588. Select relevant text evidence to answer the hypothesis question.
  • Learners should use the persuasion map tool in Read-Write-Think to prepare for a debate: https://www.readwritethink.org/classroom-resources/student-interactives/persuasion
  • Learners share their creations with classmates to survey points of view, claims, and evidence used to present ideas, prioritizing the most compelling points.
  • In small groups, learners develop and film a presentation of their major points and perspectives. These will be viewed by other teams, who score their presentations with a class-created rubric.
Tags:
Debate, Evaluate sources, Interpret symbols, Primary source analysis, Using citations, Using historical context, Visual literacy
Alternative or Complementary Primary Sources

Highsmith, Carol M. A replica of a most unusual battle flag carried by the Texan army at the Battle of San Jacinto, seen at the annual Battle of San Jacinto Festival and Battle Reenactment, a living-history retelling and demonstration of the historic Battle of San Jacinto, La Porte, Texas. 2014. Photograph. Library of Congress Prints and Photographs Division. https://www.loc.gov/item/2014633202/.

Subject/Topic:
American popular culture, Journalism/news, advertising
Is Mosaic Content
On

School Begins/Dalrymple

School Begins/Dalrymple
Lesson By
Shona Rose, PhD
Citation

Dalrymple, Louis. School begins / Dalrymple. 1899. Print. Library of Congress Prints and Photographs Division. https://www.loc.gov/item/2012647459/.

Source Type
Political Cartoons
Suggested Grade Band: Grade 9, Grade 10, Grade 11, Grade 12
Describe How Students Will Engage with the Source

The caption is Uncle Sam speaking to his new class in Civilization: “Now, children, you’ve got to learn these lessons whether you want to or not! But just take a look at the class ahead of you, and remember that, in a little while, you will feel as glad to be here as they are!” The magazine in which this image was the centerfold addressed political satire with humor. Political cartoons convey a literal meaning but also require an understanding of the relevant facts of the period. In this lesson, learners examine the literal meaning of the cartoon, explore resources about the period, and connect the literal situation conveyed in the cartoon with facts and perspectives from the period. An optional activity asks learners to alter the cartoon to reflect a modern topic.

Historical/Community Context for the Primary Source

After the Spanish American War, the US annexed many different territories, including Puerto Rico and Hawaii. “The future Secretary of State John Hay described the ensuing conflict as a ‘splendid little war’.” After isolating and defeating the Spanish Army garrisons in Cuba, the U.S. Navy destroyed the Spanish Caribbean squadron on July 3 as it attempted to escape the U.S. naval blockade of Santiago. These people from these annexed territories had different skin tones than most Americans at the time and are featured here as “unruly” children in a classroom. In the back of the classroom, the white children are all seen as behaving creating the image of what Manifest Destiny looked like in the 19th century.

Source: https://history.state.gov/milestones/1866-1898/spanish-american-war

 

Source: : https://history.state.gov/milestones/1866-1898/spanish-american-war

 

Instructional Focus Question(s) for Discussion
  1. Notice that each group of characters are depicted with different artistic styles. What does the artist’s style convey about the characters?
  2. By depicting the setting as a classroom, what main point is the artist conveying about the relationship between the “teacher” and the others in the image?
Standards Connection (State)
TX
Standards Connections

Texas

 

 

ELA Standard

E1.8(A)Multiple genres. Analyze the author’s purpose, audience, and message within a text.

Social Studies Standard

US.25B. Culture. The student understands the political, economic, and social changes in the United States from 1877 to 1898. US.25 The student is expected to (B) describe the Americanization movement to assimilate immigrants and American Indians into American culture.

NCTE Standard 1

Students read a wide range of print and non-print texts to build an understanding of texts, of themselves, and of the cultures of the United States and the world; to acquire new information; to respond to the needs and demands of society and the workplace; and for personal fulfillment. Among these texts are fiction and nonfiction, classic and contemporary works.

Instructional Design
  • Observe: Identify and note details. Label the “characters” and elements in the setting (location of characters, activities of characters, depiction of character traits and postures/facial expressions, clothing, other writing, captions, etc.)
  • Observe: What does the image depict? Read the summary provided by the Library of Congress. Add relevant notes to your annotations.
  • Reflect: From your existing knowledge, is the message positive or negative? On what topics is the cartoonist commenting?
  • Question: Note the source and date. What does the cartoonist expect the audience to know? What kind of materials does the source publish? What was going on politically during the time of publication?
  • Observe: Learners skim and scan the WebQuest sources below to build knowledge about the period, adding ideas and key terms to the annotations.
    • Imperialism, Expansionist Policies, Spanish-American War
      • https://sites.gsu.edu/ale26/2015/10/26/imperialism-cartoon-school-begins/
      • https://forgottenfiles.substack.com/p/school-begins-1899
      • https://visualizingcultures.mit.edu/civilization_and_barbarism/cb_essay03.html#:~:text=The%20image%20exhibits%20a%20racist,as%20dark%2Dskinned%20and%20childish.
      • https://aguil079.omeka.net/exhibits/show/interpretation-of-political-ca/what-do-these-images-mean-/school-begins
  • Reflect: Learners craft statements using these sentence stems: The (character) is/feels/believes ______. This demonstrates/highlights/suggests/shows that _____.
  • Encourage learners to evaluate their research and findings with the following questions: Did you find information about the Spanish-American Conflict, Hawaii’s annexation, formation of protectorates of Cuba and Puerto Rico? What did you learn about securing Guam and the Philippines? How did the artist use exaggeration, sarcasm, and symbolism to convey their point of view? How did California, Texas, New Mexico, Arizona, and Alaska connect to the message? What implications did you discover about the Native American boy, the Chinese boy, and the African American’s participation in the image?
  • Extension: How would you alter the image to convey a modern topic?
  • Additional Questions: How do we understand political cartoons (especially when we know little of the background and topic)? Once we interpret messages, how do we integrate (or reject) ideas for our own belief systems, interpretations, and voting decisions?
Tags:
Annotation, Comprehend satire, Critical inquiry, Interpret graphic images, Making inferences, Observe-Reflect-Question, Political cartoon, Primary source analysis, Research and inquiry, Satire, Skim and scan, Visual literacy
Alternative or Complementary Primary Sources

Dalrymple, Louis. He can't let go / Dalrymple. 1898. Print. Library of Congress Prints and Photographs Division. https://www.loc.gov/item/2012647490/.

Dalrymple, Louis. "Save me from my friends!" / Dalrymple. 1898. Print. Library of Congress Prints and Photographs Division. https://www.loc.gov/item/2012647469/.

Dalrymple, Louis. Some time in the future / Dalrymple. 1895. Print. Library of Congress Prints and Photographs Division. https://www.loc.gov/item/2012648643/.

Dalrymple, Louis. Uncle Sam's picnic / Dalrymple. 1898. Print. Library of Congress Prints and Photographs Division. https://www.loc.gov/item/2012647475/.

Subject/Topic:
Geography, history, social studies, Journalism/news, advertising
Is Mosaic Content
On

Image 1 of Santa Ana and Image 1 letter to Andrew Jackson

Image 1 of Santa Ana and Image 1 letter to Andrew Jackson
Lesson By
Shona Rose, PhD
Citation

de Santa Anna, Antonio Lopez, and Andrew Jackson. Andrew Jackson to Antonio Lopez de Santa Anna, September 4, 1836. 1836. Manuscript. Library of Congress Manuscript Division. https://www.loc.gov/item/maj015236/.

Jackson, Andrew, and Antonio Lopez de Santa Anna. Antonio Lopez de Santa Anna to Andrew Jackson, July 4, 1836. 1836. Manuscript. Library of Congress Manuscript Division. https://www.loc.gov/item/maj015091/.

Source Type
Books and Other Printed Texts Manuscripts
Suggested Grade Band: Grade 9, Grade 10, Grade 11, Grade 12
Describe How Students Will Engage with the Source

Andrew Jackson and Santa Anna communicated after the Battle of San Jacinto during the Texas Revolution. Santa Anna was a prisoner of war and wrote to the United States to seek support and his release. Jackson responded to protect peace and future negotiations with Mexico but also recognized Texas independence.

Historical/Community Context for the Primary Source

In 1836, Santa Anna wrote to President Andew Jackson, who replied two months later. Santa Anna had been detained by the Texas army, and he asked President Jackson to intervene on his behalf. Texas President Houston writes of these events in Romance and Tragedy of Texas History; being a record of many thrilling events in Texas history under Spanish, Mexican, and Anglo-Saxon rule, also in the Library of Congress offerings. First, learners read the correspondence to infer what events surround the letters. Then, learners validate or adjust their predictions based on Houston’s account of the events.

 

Source: https://www.sonsofdewittcolony.org/santaanna4.htm

 

Instructional Focus Question(s) for Discussion
  1. How does correspondence document history?
  2. How does correspondence help readers understand the character of historical figures beyond the historical recitations and facts in history textbooks?
  3. How is correspondence adapted or abandoned in modern culture? What are the implications of modern modes of communication on the documentation of history?
Standards Connection (State)
TX
Standards Connections

Texas

 

ELA Standard

EI.4C. Comprehension. The students use metacognitive skills to both develop and deepen comprehension of increasingly complex texts. (C) generate questions about the text before, during, and after reading to deepen understanding and gain information.

Social Studies Standard

USH(HS) 28A. Social studies skills. The student understands how historians use historiography to interpret the past and applies critical-thinking skills to organize and uses information acquired from a variety of valid sources, including technology. (A) The student is expected to analyze primary and secondary sources such as maps, graphs, speeches, political cartoons, and artifacts to acquire information to answer historical questions.

NCTE Standard 3

Students apply a wide range of strategies to comprehend, interpret, evaluate, and appreciate texts. They draw on their prior experience, their interactions with other readers and writers, their knowledge of word meaning and of other texts, their word identification strategies, and their understanding of textual features (e.g., sound-letter correspondence, sentence structure, context, graphics).

Instructional Design
  • Introduce correspondence between Santa Anna and Andrew Jackson. Who are these men, and why are they writing letters to each other? What happened before the letters were written?
  • Ask learners to use the letters to fill in the answers to the basic reporter’s questions: Who, What, Where, When, Why, and How. They may also use a general timeline to document when the events occurred.
  • After learners have had time to build knowledge of the content in the letters, bring learners into small groups. What questions remain? What do we not know? Learners add these questions to their reporter’s notes.
  • Present Houston’s narrative of Santa Anna’s capture and the following events: Romance and tragedy of Texas history; being a record of many thrilling events in Texas history under Spanish, Mexican and Anglo-Saxon rule. Learners add to their notes, cross out inaccuracies, and make adjustments to their initial findings.
  • Debrief the experience with the class: What did we learn from the letters and firsthand accounts that we may have missed from a more encyclopedic treatment of the events?
  • Using the letter generator from Read-Write-Think interactives, learners write a letter to Santa Anna, Houston, or Andrew Jackson about what a learner in 2025 learned about history from correspondence. Learners may also choose to write a letter to next year’s class, asking them to consider the importance of using correspondence in daily life to document events and communicate with others.
Tags:
Correspondence, Primary source analysis, Questions, Using timelines to trace comprehension, Visual literacy
Alternative or Complementary Primary Sources

Thrall, Homer S. A pictorial history of Texas, from the earliest visits of European adventurers, to A.D. 1879. St. Louis: N. D. Thompson & Co., 1879. https://www.loc.gov/item/01006596/.

Subject/Topic:
Geography, history, social studies, Government, law, politics, Language, literature, folklore
Is Mosaic Content
On

Texas Panhandle for the home seeker, capitalist, and tourist

Texas Panhandle for the home seeker, capitalist, and tourist
Lesson By
Shona Rose, PhD
Citation

Union Pacific Railroad Company, and Benjamin H. Barrows. The resources and attractions of the Texas Panhandle for the home seeker, capitalist, and tourist. St. Louis: Woodward & Tiernan Printing Co., 1893. https://www.loc.gov/item/rc01002575/.

Source Type
Books and Other Printed Texts Manuscripts
Suggested Grade Band: Grade 6, Grade 7, Grade 8
Describe How Students Will Engage with the Source

Learners will read the accounts of settlers to gather evidence on whether or not a person can make a living farming/ranching in the Panhandle of Texas. Was it a good idea for a farmer to settle in the Panhandle of Texas? Learners will then explore contemporary sources to decide if Goodnight’s (see note below) opinions are valid (pages 112–113 of the resource).

Historical/Community Context for the Primary Source

By the time of this publication, the buffalo were gone. The Indians were contained for the most part. Folks learned about the grassland of the Panhandle Plains and sought to graze sheep and cattle. Large ranches and corporations developed. Goodnight advises the authors about the enterprise. Charles Goodnight is often called the “Father of the Panhandle” because of his influence in settling the west. His wife, Mary Ann, is credited for saving the last of the bison from extinction in the 1880s.

Source: https://www.tshaonline.org/handbook/entries/panhandle

https://www.tshaonline.org/handbook/entries/ranching

 

Source: : https://www.tshaonline.org/handbook/entries/panhandle

https://www.tshaonline.org/handbook/entries/ranching

 

Instructional Focus Question(s) for Discussion
  1. According to Goodnight, what are the pros and cons of farming or ranching in the Panhandle of Texas?
  2. Which of Goodnight’s statements are facts? Which are opinions?
Standards Connection (State)
TX
Standards Connections

Texas

 

 

ELA Standard

8:6 J. Response skills: listening, speaking, reading, writing, and thinking using multiple texts. The student responds to an increasingly challenging variety of sources that are read, heard, or viewed. (J) The student is expected to defend or challenge the actors’ claims using relevant text evidence.

Social Studies Standard

8.6B. History: The student understands westward expansion and its effects on the political, economic, and social development of the nation. The student is expected to (B) analyze the westward growth of the nation, including the Louisiana Purchase and Manifest Destiny.

NCTE Standard 5

Students employ a wide range of strategies as they write and use different writing process elements appropriately to communicate with different audiences for a variety of purposes.

Instructional Design
  • Begin with an open-ended question: Is it a good idea to be a farmer or rancher? Allow learners time to jot down their ideas in two columns with the headers Good Idea, Bad Idea. Under each column, they should list reasons they believe farming/ranching would be a good or bad idea. Give learners time to share ideas and add to their charts.
  • Propose the idea that historical accounts help us learn from other people’s experiences. Present the resources. Learners put a plus or minus sign in the margins, indicating whether Goodnight thought farming and ranching were good or bad ideas. Learners underline or highlight relevant text evidence that can be used in their response. Show learners how to skim and scan to find relevant information in the supplementary text on the history of farming and ranching in the Panhandle. Learners collect positive and negative insights as before as well as text evidence that is useful to quote in their responses.
  • Give learners the following kernel structure for an essay that answers whether or not it is a good idea to be a farmer or rancher. Some people think __________. And other people think _________. But I think _______. What that tells me is _________. Learners fill in the blanks and add additional text evidence and explanation from the sources provided.
  • After students complete their drafts, allow them to meet in pairs to see how other learners answered the questions.
  • As a whole-class debrief, pose the following question: By examining historical and modern accounts, what did we learn about decision making?
  • Additional Focus Questions:
    • How do people make financial decisions about their professions?
    • We are told that we can learn from history. What does Goodnight’s account reveal about the viability of farming and ranching in the Panhandle of Texas in modern times?
    • What powerful claims and warrants are available in Goodnight’s account that could be used for an argumentative stance on the probability of financial success in farming and ranching in the Panhandle of Texas?
    • In other words, how do the accounts from a historical perspective impact modern decision making?

Note: This site has a flip book, searchable for terms: https://archive.org/details/resourcesattract10unio/mode/2up

Tags:
Annotation, Argumentative response, Primary source analysis, Quotations, Selecting text evidence, Using evidence to support claims, Visual literacy
Alternative or Complementary Primary Sources

Historic American Buildings Survey. Charles Goodnight Ranch House, Goodnight, Armstrong County, TX. 1933. Print. Library of Congress Prints and Photographs Division. https://www.loc.gov/item/tx1056/.

Subject/Topic:
Geography, history, social studies, Language, literature, folklore
Is Mosaic Content
On

Federal Writers’ Project: Slave Narrative Project

Federal Writers’ Project: Slave Narrative Project
Lesson By
Shona Rose, PhD
Citation

Federal Writers' Project: Slave Narrative Project, Vol. 16, Texas, Part 4, Sanco-Young. 1936. Manuscript. Library of Congress Manuscript Division. https://www.loc.gov/item/mesn164/.

Source Type
Oral Histories
Suggested Grade Band: Grade 9, Grade 10, Grade 11, Grade 12
Describe How Students Will Engage with the Source

Learners receive one of 50 names from the resource. Learners choose notetaking, annotation, freewriting, or illustrating as methods to interact with the source. Next, learners respond to book, head, and heart prompts to guide their initial reflections about the text. Finally, learners reflect on the overarching question of what personal narratives reveal about history and the human experience. Writers select relevant text evidence and draw specific conclusions from the source about their observations and reflections using the Trading Card Tool from Read-Write-Think.

Historical/Community Context for the Primary Source

The Library of Congress sponsored The Federal Writers’ Project as a part of the Work Projects Administration between 1936–1938. Part four includes interviews from former slaves living in Texas. Interviews were transcribed and typed to preserve dialect and tone of delivery as much as possible. More about the collection is described here. Also relevant is the report on the Language of Narratives, as the diction will be offensive to modern readers.

 

Source: Works Progress Administration

Federal Writers’Project

 

Source: : Works Progress Administration

Federal Writers’Project

 

Instructional Focus Question(s) for Discussion
  1. When you read the narrative(s), what surprises you?
  2. What do the speakers and writers think the audience already knows?
  3. What changes, challenges, or confirms your understandings. (These questions are from Beers and Probst in Disrupting Thinking.)
Standards Connection (State)
TX
Standards Connections

Texas

 

 

ELA Standard

E1.5E. Response: listening, speaking, reading, writing, and thinking using multiple texts. 5. The student responds to an increasingly challenging variety of sources that are read, heard, or viewed. The student is expected to (E) interact with sources in meaningful ways such as notetaking, annotating, freewriting, or illustrating.

Social Studies Standard

8.29C. Social studies skills: The student communicates in written, oral, and visual forms. The student is expected to apply foundational language skills to engage in civil discourse about social studies topics, including those with multiple perspectives.

NCTE Standard 6

Students apply knowledge of language structure, language conventions (e.g., spelling and punctuation), media techniques, figurative language, and genre to create, critique, and discuss print and non-print texts.

Instructional Design
  • On index cards, write the names and page numbers from images 4, 5, and 6 of the resource. Allow learners to select a name that resonates with them and navigate to the appropriate image in the resource.
  • Learners read the selected narrative, selecting notetaking, annotating, freewriting, or illustrating as their method of interaction. Learners write a summary of an interesting segment or the whole text using a method such as the “Somebody . . . wanted . . . but . . . so . . . then . . .” technique.
  • Learners meet in small groups to share their insights about what they have read in the narratives.
  • Learners then take time to freewrite: What’s in your head? What surprised you as a reader? And what’s in your heart? Share how you feel about what you learned or discovered. This bookmark from Beers and Probst might also be helpful.
  • Learners meet in small groups to read aloud from their reflections. On the first reading, listeners just listen and gather the gist of the writer’s thoughts. On the second reading, the listeners jot down words and phrases that stuck out to them from the writer’s response. One at a time, listeners give the notes to the writer, explaining why they chose those words or phrases.
  • The teacher then leads a class discussion on what the narratives revealed about history and the human experience. Learners are asked to read particular excerpts from the text to support their conclusions. The QA12345 method may provide a scaffold for discussion. Question: How do narratives reveal history and the human experience? Answer: (learner’s choice) 1: How do you know? (text evidence) 2: What does that mean? (commentary and interpretation) 3: How else do you know? (another topic, learner’s choice) 4: What does that mean? (commentary and interpretation) 5: Conclusion—so, this means what?
  • Learners then use the Trading Card Tool to represent the life of the person they read about. Learners include relevant text evidence from the narrative as well as items from the whole-class debrief.
  • Learners share the trading cards in a display of what they have learned from the narratives.
  • Additional Questions
    • When we read, how do the words impact both our “head” and our “heart”? (Book, Head, Heart by Beers and Probst)
    • What do personal narratives reveal about history and the human experience?
Tags:
Annotation, Claims and commentary, Illustrating, Notetaking, Personal narrative, Primary source analysis, Response to text, Selecting text evidence, Summarizing, Visual literacy, Writing with dialect
Alternative or Complementary Primary Sources

Jas. Boyd, ex-slave, Waco. 1937. Photograph. Library of Congress Prints and Photographs Division. https://www.loc.gov/item/99615246/.

Monroe Brackins, ex-slave, Hondo. 1937. Library of Congress Prints and Photographs Division. Photograph. https://www.loc.gov/item/99615247/.

Monroe Brackins, ex-slave, Hondo. Between 1937 and ca. 1938. Photograph. Prints and Photographs Division. https://www.loc.gov/item/99615248/.

Nelson Denson, ex-slave, Waco. 1937. Photograph. Library of Congress Prints and Photographs Division. https://www.loc.gov/item/99615279/.

Wes Brady, ex-slave, Marshall. 1937. Photograph. Library of Congress Prints and Photographs Division. https://www.loc.gov/item/99615249/.

William Branch. Between 1937 and ca. 1938. Photograph. Library of Congress Prints and Photographs Division. https://www.loc.gov/item/99615250/.

Subject/Topic:
Geography, history, social studies, Literature/informational text, Journalism/news, advertising
Is Mosaic Content
On

The Fredericksburg Home Kitchen Cook Book

The Fredericksburg Home Kitchen Cook Book
Lesson By
Shona Rose, PhD
Citation

The Fredericksburg home kitchen cook book. Fredericksburg: Public School Auxiliary of Fredericksburg, Texas, 1921. https://www.loc.gov/item/21004722/.

Source Type
Books and Other Printed Texts Manuscripts
Suggested Grade Band: Grade 3, Grade 4, Grade 5
Describe How Students Will Engage with the Source

By examining Texas history, learners will discover the influence of immigration in Texas communities. In this cookbook, learners will experience the German influence of foods eaten in the community of Fredericksburg. Learners will receive a list of German influences in cuisine, will skim and scan the cookbook for recipes, and will craft a menu to reflect the mix of cultures during the 1900s era in Fredericksburg, Texas.

Historical/Community Context for the Primary Source

Written by the Fredericksburg Public School Auxiliary to celebrate the 75th anniversary of the founding of Fredericksburg, Texas. Image 8 in the collection shows a black-and-white photo of the Community Church and First School. Pages 7 and 8 of the book describe the cooking and culture on the Pedernales. Sections follow to describe relishes; soups; oysters and fish; poultry and game; meats, macaroni, rice, pancakes, eggs, potatoes, etc.; vegetables; salads; puddings; pastry, pies, tarts; bread, coffee, cake, doughnuts, etc.

Instructional Focus Question(s) for Discussion
  1. What do you notice about how food and culture connect?
  2. What do recipes tell you about life in a particular time period?
  3. By reading about what people ate, what else would you like to know?
Standards Connection (State)
TX
Standards Connections

Texas

 

ELA Standard

4.7B. Response Skills: listening, speaking, reading, writing, and thinking using multiple texts. The student responds to an increasingly challenging variety of sources that are read, heard, or viewed. (B) The student is expected to write responses that demonstrate understanding of texts, including comparing and contrasting ideas across a variety of sources.

Social Studies Standard

4.11C. History: The student is expected to identify the effects of exploration, immigration, migration, and limited resources on the economic development and growth of Texas.

NCTE Standard 1

Students read a wide range of print and non-print texts to build an understanding of texts, of themselves, and of the cultures of the United States and the world; to acquire new information; to respond to the needs and demands of society and the workplace; and for personal fulfillment. Among these texts are fiction and nonfiction, classic and contemporary works.

Instructional Design
  • Ask students the question: Would you eat that? Show images of pork sausages (wurst); potatoes (dumplings, Kartoffelknödel, Spätzle) ; breads (Brot, Brotchen, rye, yeast doughs and pastries); cabbage (sauerkraut); things with flavors of sweet and sour from vinegar, sugar, fruit; spices (of caraway, mustard, juniper berries, parsley, dill, marjoram, thyme, bay leaves, paprika, nutmeg, cinnamon, cloves, ginger, allspice, horseradish, and black pepper); cooked (by braising Sauerbraten), pickling, curing, smoking; desserts with apples, plums, cherries (cakes, tarts, cookies, Schwarzwälder Kirschtorte).
  • These foods come from the German culture. A town in Texas, Fredericksburg, began to help German immigrants. Present the cookbook.
  • Allow learners to skim and scan the recipes, looking for German influences. Ask learners to prepare a menu of German-influenced recipes from the cookbook, including appetizers, main dish, vegetables, breads, relishes, and a dessert.
  • Allow learners to share their menus.
  • Conduct a whole-class debrief about the experience using the instructional focus questions in this lesson.
Tags:
Making inferences, Primary source analysis, Skim and scan, Text evidence, Visual literacy, Vocabulary, Writing process
Alternative or Complementary Primary Sources

Highsmith, Carol M. Built by Christian Herry in 1878, Gruene Hall in New Braunfels is one of the oldest dance halls in Texas. 2014. Photograph. Library of Congress Prints and Photographs Division. https://www.loc.gov/item/2014632377/.

Highsmith, Carol M. The 1872 Gruene Family Home, a Victorian-style house in the German-immigrant cotton-farming community of Gruene, now part of New Braunfels, Texas. 2014. Photograph. Library of Congress Prints and Photographs Division. https://www.loc.gov/item/2014632384/.

Highsmith, Carol M. A small, centrally located community building in the old German-immigrant settlement of Gruene, now part of New Braunfels, Texas. 2014. Photograph. Library of Congress Prints and Photographs Division. https://www.loc.gov/item/2014632392/.

Subject/Topic:
American popular culture, Geography, history, social studies
Is Mosaic Content
On

The farmer

The farmer
Lesson By
Dr. Chea Parton
Citation

Curtis, Edward S, photographer. The farmer. New Mexico, ca. 1905. Photograph. https://www.loc.gov/item/94513353/.

Source Type
Photographs and Prints
Suggested Grade Band: Grade 6, Grade 7, Grade 8
Describe How Students Will Engage with the Source

After students research and learn about the forced removal of Native peoples, Edward Curtis, and fry bread, they will look closely at the photograph and consider why the photograph is titled “The farmer” and how it is connected or disconnected to how we think of farmers today.

Historical/Community Context for the Primary Source

Native Americans make up a significant portion of rural populations in the US; however, they are often excluded from the homogenous population usually connoted by the term “rural.” Researching and exploring the tensions of Edward Curtis’s larger body of work, including the photograph titled “The farmer” and the difficulty forced removal created for Native farmers, allows for nuanced understanding of rural peoples.

Source: https://www.britannica.com/topic/fry-bread

Instructional Focus Question(s) for Discussion
  1. What details do we notice in the photograph? What do they reveal/tell us?
  2. How do the titles of work influence our understanding of them?
  3. How, if at all, is “The farmer” an apt title for this photograph?
Standards Connection (State)
IN
Standards Connections

Indiana

ELA Standard

8.CC.4: Analyze the purpose of information presented in diverse media and formats (e.g., visually, quantitatively, orally) and evaluate the motives (e.g., social, commercial, political) behind its presentation.

Social Studies Standard

8.H.1 Identify the major Native American groups of eastern North America, and identify cause and effect relationships between European settlers and these Native American groups that led to conflict and cooperation.

NCTE Standard 1

Students read a wide range of print and non-print texts to build an understanding of texts, of themselves, and of the cultures of the United States and the world

Instructional Design
  • Read students Fry Bread by Kevin Noble Maillard and review/discuss the food scarcity Native people faced when they were forcibly removed from their homelands.
  • Split students up into small groups and have them Google “American farmer.” Have them take note of the images that appear. Who is there? Who is missing? What do they notice about the way the subjects of the photographs are dressed? Do they think these images are an accurate representation of American farmers? Why/why not?
  • As a whole class, allow students to share their findings. Then discuss, “What can we learn about people and culture from photographs?”
  • Project the image of the “The farmer” without telling students the title of the image and ask them to read it closely, offering to the class what they notice about the photograph.
  • Ask students what they infer from the picture. Who is the subject? What is he doing? Where does he live?
  • When they have exhausted their noticing, tell them the title of the photo and the historical background: it was taken in 1905; the man is Hopi. Ask students how it changes what they see. Does anything become clearer or less so?
  • After finishing the discussion, invite students to choose to write a letter from the subject of Curtis’s photograph to one of the following: (a) farmers today; (b) Curtis; (c) modern American people. What would he want them to know? What wisdom might he offer? What questions might he have for them?
Tags:
Close reading, Letter writing, Making inferences, Primary source analysis, Read aloud, Visual analysis
Alternative or Complementary Primary Sources

Curtis, Edward S, photographer. The cornfield, ca. 1906, December 19. Photograph. https://www.loc.gov/item/2003652704/.

Subject/Topic:
Geography, history, social studies, Photographs, prints, posters
Is Mosaic Content
On

Robber Barons Cave/ Harvey Patteson

Robber Barons Cave/ Harvey Patteson
Lesson By
Katrina Simmons
Citation

Patteson, Harvey. Robber Barons Cave / Harvey Patteson. 1923. Photograph. Library of Congress Prints and Photographs Division. https://www.loc.gov/item/2012646088/.

Source Type
Photographs and Prints
Suggested Grade Band: Kindergarten, Grade 1, Grade 2
Describe How Students Will Engage with the Source

Students will observe the photo of Robber Baron Cave and discuss what they think is happening. They will hear an overview of the cave’s history both as a landform and as one of the first commercial caves in Texas. After discussing the purpose of the photograph as an advertisement for a kind of amusement park in the early 1900s, students will learn about the current mission of the cave. In small groups, they will create an updated advertisement for the caves and present it in a tableau.

Historical/Community Context for the Primary Source

Robber Baron Cave is located in the urban area of San Antonio, Texas, and is the longest known cave in the county. Over a mile’s worth of passages have been mapped out. The cave is full of history and lore—for about a decade before the Great Depression, it was even used as a tourist attraction. The image is a posed picture used in the advertisement campaign for the commercial venture of George C. Saur.

 

Source: https://www.tcmacaves.org/preserves/robberbaron/

 

Source: : https://www.tcmacaves.org/preserves/robberbaron/

 

Instructional Focus Question(s) for Discussion
  1. What kind of story does the marketing photo of Robber Baron Cave convey to the viewer?
    1. What was the purpose for continuing and expanding on legends of hidden treasures and outlaws surrounding the cave?
    2. What aspects of this photo might today’s current owners of the cave keep to promote the modern-day mission of the cave? What aspects might they change and why?
Standards Connection (State)
TX
Standards Connections

Texas

 

ELA Standards

5.1.D. Developing and sustaining foundational language skills. Work collaboratively with others to develop a plan of shared responsibilities.

Science Standard

5.11. Earth and space. The student understands how natural resources are important and can be managed. The student is expected to design and explain solutions such as conservation, recycling, or proper disposal to minimize environmental impact of the use of natural resources.

NCTE Standard 12

Students use spoken, written, and visual language to accomplish their own purposes (e.g., for learning, enjoyment, persuasion, and the exchange of information).

Instructional Design
  • Show students the picture of Robber Baron Cave. Invite them to wonder what is going on in the picture.
    • What do they notice?
    • What do they think it means?
  • Divide the students into five groups and jigsaw an online article about the Robber Baron Cave. Have each group read one section of the history section (Legends of Los Quebrantahuesos, 1920s: Open to the Public [divide in 2], 1950s: Neighborhood Expansion, 1960s to 1990s: Cavers and Surveys) at the preservation site for Robber Baron Cave (https://www.tcmacaves.org/preserves/robberbaron/history/ ). Groups should write down 3 to 5 important facts from the sections they read.
  • Have one or two representatives summarize what their group read, discussing how the actual history of the cave has been influenced by stories and legends of the community surrounding it.
  • After going through each group, ask students to identify which part of history the image is from. Ensure that they understand the image is staged and part of an advertising campaign to present the caves in a certain way to the public.
    • Is the image real or staged?
    • Why did the owner of the caves choose to market them in this way? (The idea of the Wild West was enticing, He wanted to attract people to visit, etc.)
    • How has the goal of the current owners changed? What do they hope to achieve? (Research, education, preservation, safety, etc.)
  • In their groups, have students consider how the current owners might try to convey the current mission if they had an advertising campaign. Imagine one image they might create to highlight the updated mission of the Robber Baron Cave. Each group will create a tableau of this image and present it to the class.
  • To wrap up, have students write a short reflection on how our priorities with how we interact with Earth’s natural resources change throughout history and how we balance our desires to interact with them and our desires to learn from and preserve them.
Tags:
Image analysis, Jigsaw, Primary source analysis, Reflection, Small group, Tableau, Visual literacy
Alternative or Complementary Primary Sources

Patteson, Harvey. Robber Barons Cave / Harvey Patteson. 1923. Photograph. Library of Congress Prints and Photographs Division. https://www.loc.gov/item/2012646089/.

Subject/Topic:
American popular culture, Photography
Is Mosaic Content
On

Bat Roost, San Antonio

Bat Roost, San Antonio
Lesson By
Katrina Simmons
Citation

Bain News Service. Bat Roost, San Antonio. ca. 1915. Photograph. Library of Congress Prints and Photographs Division. https://www.loc.gov/item/2014699615/.

Source Type
Photographs and Prints
Suggested Grade Band: Grade 3, Grade 4, Grade 5
Describe How Students Will Engage with the Source

Students will have the opportunity to consider how the animals in our environment affect the ecosystems they are a part of by considering the addition of the Bat Roost in San Antonio, Texas. After observing the image and defining what a roost is, students will research how bats contribute to the environment. Then, they will write a letter to the 1915 San Antonio City Council, proposing why they should build bat roosts around the city.

Historical/Community Context for the Primary Source

Malaria was a concern for communities in the early 1900s. Dr. Charles Augustus Rosenheimer Campbell was a doctor who attempted to attract bats to the area in an effort to help control mosquitos that carried the disease. He built large bat roosts for the animals to rest in, hoping it would attract them to the area.

 

Source: https://www.tshaonline.org/handbook/entries/campbell-charles-augustus-rosenheimer

 

Instructional Focus Question(s) for Discussion
  1. Looking at the image, what can you tell about its purpose?
    1. What is a bat roost?
    2. How big is the structure?
    3. Why do you think they included a cross at the top?
  2. After some research opportunities, students can answer several of the following extension questions:
    1. How did Dr. Charles Augustus Rosenheimer Campbell impact his community?
    2. Why did he want to build this bat roost?
    3. What was he trying to accomplish by building such large structures?
    4. How symbiotic was the relationship he attempted to create between the city and the bats?
    5. What other problems might we be able to solve by looking more closely at the world and environment around us and focusing on how things connect to one another?
Standards Connection (State)
TX
Standards Connections

Texas

 

ELA Standard

3.12.D. Composition. Compose correspondence such as thank you notes or letters.

Science Standard

5.12.A. Organisms and environment. Observe and describe how a variety of organisms survive by interacting with biotic and abiotic factors in a healthy ecosystem.

NCTE Standard 4

Students adjust their use of spoken, written, and visual language (e.g., conventions, style, vocabulary) to communicate effectively with a variety of audiences and for different purposes.

Instructional Design
  • Begin the lesson with a quickwrite. Ask students to list everything that comes to mind when they think of the animal, the bat. Have students share what comes to mind and document their ideas on the board. Discuss the physical characteristics they might know, connections to pop culture/ literature, and how people feel about bats.
  • Next, show them the image of the bat roost and ask them what they see. If students seem to have run out of observations, you may want to enlarge sections of the image (especially if they do not notice the name of the city at the top or the man standing just under the Municipal Bat Roost sign).
  • Ask students to theorize what the structure might be used for. Also see if anyone knows what a roost is. If not, explain that a roost is a place where birds and bats rest.
  • Once they have had a chance to share their wonderings at what the structure might be used for, explain that it was the idea of Dr. Charles Augustus Rosenheimer Campbell. During the time he lived, malaria was a serious illness that was mostly transmitted by mosquitoes. He knew that bats are mostly insectivores—that is, they eat moths, flies, beetles, and mosquitoes. He thought that by building the roosts throughout the city, he would attract them to rest and hoped that while they were in the area, they would consume many mosquitoes.
  • Have the students consider how people in the community may have felt about someone trying to attract bats closer to their homes.
    • Do you think everyone felt safe and happy about the idea?
    • Do you think they everyone was happy about the look and size of the structures?
    • Do you think everyone agreed to building the bat roosts right away?
  • Convincing his community to build bat roosts was probably not simple. He probably had to present many positive facts about bats before the city would pass an ordinance. Individually or in small groups, have students research ways that bats benefit the environment. They can use library books or school databases. There are also a many web articles, including those at National Geographic for Kids (https://kids.nationalgeographic.com/nature/article/bat-myths-busted), Bat Conservation International (https://www.batcon.org/about-bats/games-and-activities/bat-squad/), and Britannica for Kids (https://kids.britannica.com/kids/article/bat/352835), to name a few options.
  • Once facts have been collected, students should draft a letter to the San Antonio City Council of 1915 trying to convince them why building the bat roosts would be beneficial to the city.
  • If time allows, students could also look up current proposals to city council, research the proposal, and write a letter to their current council member laying out their view on the proposal.
Tags:
Letter writing, Primary source analysis, Quickwrite, Research, Visual literacy
Alternative or Complementary Primary Sources

Giltsch, Adolf, and Ernst Haeckel. Chiroptera. — Fledertiere. 1904. Print. Library of Congress Prints and Photographs Division. https://www.loc.gov/item/2015648949/.

Subject/Topic:
Geography, history, social studies, Language, literature, folklore
Is Mosaic Content
On

Emma Ortega, Lipan Apache

Emma Ortega, Lipan Apache
Lesson By
Katrina Simmons
Citation

Highsmith, Carol M. Emma Ortega, 75, a participant of Lipan Apache heritage at the Celebrations of Traditions Pow Wow, an official Native American Pow Wow that is part of the annual, month-long Fiesta San Antonio in Texas. 2014. Photograph. Library of Congress Prints and Photographs Division. https://www.loc.gov/item/2014632485/.

Source Type
Photographs and Prints
Suggested Grade Band: Grade 3, Grade 4, Grade 5
Describe How Students Will Engage with the Source

Students will look at the picture of Emma Ortega and use visual clues to make inferences about who she is and what she might be dressed for. After discussing their observations, they will have the opportunity to experience the modern-day powwow through books, images, and videos. Students should gain an appreciation for the past and the present of the Native American people. They will also have the chance to reflect on events in their own lives that connect them to their own culture and identity.

Historical/Community Context for the Primary Source

Intertribal and intratribal social gatherings filled with song and dance have been a part of Native American culture for centuries, but the tradition of the modern powwow is more recent. These events allow Indigenous Americans to reaffirm their native identities, regardless of whether they reside on a reservation or not. Oftentimes, they are open to the public and allow local residents to become educated about American Indian culture.

Source: https://www.lipanapache.org/LAT/powwows.html

 

Source: : https://www.lipanapache.org/LAT/powwows.html

 

Instructional Focus Question(s) for Discussion
  1. What is it about Emma Ortega’s clothing and stature that gives us insight into her culture and identity?
    1. Extension Questions
      1. How do the things we wear connect us to our past and our present?
      2. Is it important to belong to communities of people who share our cultural backgrounds?
      3. How do events that center on cultural and religious aspects preserve the history of those who are a part of them?
  2. How might members of Emma Ortega’s community see and understand the powwow, and what she is wearing in a way that those outside the community might not? Is it important to take part in communities of people/events who differ from our own cultural backgrounds?
Standards Connection (State)
TX
Standards Connections

Texas

 

ELA Standards

4.6.E. Comprehension skills. Make connections to personal experiences, ideas in other texts, and society.

Social Studies Standard

4.1.D. History. Locate American Indian groups remaining in Texas such as the Ysleta Del Sur Pueblo, Alabama-Coushatta, and Kickapoo.

NCTE Standard 5

Students employ a wide range of strategies as they write and use different writing process elements appropriately to communicate with different audiences for a variety of purposes.

Instructional Design
  • In small groups, students will be given a copy of the picture of Emma Ortega to discuss (other images from the same series may also be used). Ask them to look closely at their image. Guide them to discuss what they infer from what they see. Questions you might pose to groups needing support to begin or dive deeper:
    • What is this person wearing?
    • What is she holding?
    • What kinds of colors and patterns do you see?
    • What do these things remind you of?
    • When do you think this picture was taken?
  • As a whole group, share what students observed. Keep a list of observations for the class to see. Discuss the inferences that were made, and once students have gone through all the things they noticed and thought, share with them the fact this photo was taken in 2014 at the Celebration of Traditions Pow Wow where Ms. Ortega was a participant of the Lipan Apache heritage. Have students personally reflect on whether or not they think of Native Americans as a part of our present or whether they only think of them as part of our past.
  • Show students books, images, and/or videos of a modern powwow (i.e., Powwow Day by Traci Sorrell, Powwow: A Celebration through Song and Dance by Karen Pheasant-Neganigwane, or https://www.powwows.com/main/native-american-information-students-teachers/ )
  • In the same way that a powwow connects Native Americans to their culture and identity, ask students to think about an event they participate in with their family that connects them to their own culture or identity. It could be something dealing with their heritage, their religion, or even just a personal family tradition. Have students quickwrite a list of important things related to the event, including setting, food, music, clothing, who is invited, etc.
  • Students can describe their event to a partner or the class. Have the students use their ideas to write a personal narrative describing their chosen event. They can bring in a picture or sketch an image from the event to accompany their writing.
Tags:
Personal narrative, Primary source analysis, Quickwrite, Small group, Visual literacy
Alternative or Complementary Primary Sources

Highsmith, Carol M. Emma Ortega, 75, a participant of Lipan Apache heritage at the Celebrations of Traditions Pow Wow, an official Native American Pow Wow that is part of the annual, month-long Fiesta San Antonio in Texas. 2014. Photograph. Library of Congress Prints and Photographs Division. https://www.loc.gov/item/2014632486/.

Subject/Topic:
Arts and culture, Geography, history, social studies
Is Mosaic Content
On

Largest Cowboy Boots

Largest Cowboy Boots
Lesson By
Katrina Simmons
Citation

Margolies, John. Largest cowboy boots, Access Road, I-410 [The sculpture, formally titled the "Biggest Cowboy Boots in the World" was copyrighted by artist Bob Wade.], San Antonio, Texas. 1982. Photograph. Library of Congress Prints and Photographs Division. https://www.loc.gov/item/2017705892/.

Source Type
Photographs and Prints
Suggested Grade Band: Grade 3, Grade 4, Grade 5
Describe How Students Will Engage with the Source

Students will be presented with the picture of the world’s largest cowboy boots, making observations about the style and size. Then, students will explore items in other cities and towns that hold the record for world’s largest items. Students will choose one item they find and create a tall tale using the item as inspiration for their story.

Historical/Community Context for the Primary Source

Created by artist Bob Wade, the world’s largest cowboy boots are located in front of North Star Mall in San Antonio, Texas. Though originally created using scrap metal for the Washington Project for the Arts in 1979, the boots have been in San Antonio since January 1980.

Source: https://texashighways.com/travel/roadside-oddity-the-worlds-largest-cowboy-boots/

 

Source: : https://texashighways.com/travel/roadside-oddity-the-worlds-largest-cowboy-boots/

 

Instructional Focus Question(s) for Discussion
  1. What is the significance of the size and style of the boots in front of the San Antonio mall?
    1. Why do you think the artist chose to make boots instead of some other footwear?
    2. How do boots fit into the fabric of Texas’ history, culture, and folklore?
Standards Connection (State)
TX
Standards Connections

Texas

 

ELA Standard

4.9.A. Multiple genres. Demonstrate knowledge of distinguishing characteristics of well-known children's literature such as folktales, fables, legends, myths, and tall tales.

Social Studies Standard

4.17. Culture. The student understands the contributions of people of various racial, ethnic, and religious groups to Texas culture.

NCTE Standard 6

Students apply knowledge of language structure, language conventions (e.g., spelling and punctuation), media techniques, figurative language, and genre to create, critique, and discuss print and nonprint texts.

Instructional Design
  • Students will begin by viewing the image of the world’s largest cowboy boots. Discuss what they notice in the picture:
    • What is the style of boots?
    • What materials do they appear to be made of?
    • What can you tell about the size of the sculpture from the picture?
    • Why might the artist choose to make such a large sculpture of something so common, and why do you think he chose boots instead of some other kind of shoe?
  • Share with students the fact that the sculpture is located in San Antonio, Texas, but originally, it was created for Washington, D.C. After three months, they no longer wanted the sculpture, and it was purchased by the owners of North Star Mall. You can show them images of the dismantling and moving process to help highlight just how large the boots are. https://texashighways.com/travel/roadside-oddity-the-worlds-largest-cowboy-boots/
    • Why do you think the owners would purchase this piece of artwork that another city no longer wanted?
    • What does this sculpture say about the importance of boots in the daily life and culture as Texans?
  • Following the discussion, let students explore other world’s largest roadside attractions. There are multiple sites with curated lists (https://www.bigroads.com/articles-worldslargest.html or https://www.batchgeo.com/map/roadside-attractions). Have them write down their top 3–5 attractions.
  • Once students have their list, have them choose one as the inspiration for writing their own tall tale. Before writing begins, review the characteristics of tall tales, reminding students of the genre’s extensive use of figurative language and exaggeration. Students can use a well-known figure from tall tales, or they can create their own.
  • Allow students to read their stories to their classmates, encouraging the use of animated storytelling.
Tags:
Creative writing, Figurative language, Primary source analysis, Tall tales, Visual literacy
Alternative or Complementary Primary Sources

Margolies, John. World's largest buffalo (46' long, 26' high, 60 tons), Jamestown, North Dakota. 1990. Photograph. Library of Congress Prints and Photographs Division. https://www.loc.gov/item/2017702790/.

Subject/Topic:
Arts and culture, Geography, history, social studies, Photography
Is Mosaic Content
On

San Antonio newsboys need supervision

San Antonio newsboys need supervision
Lesson By
Katrina Simmons
Citation

Hine, Lewis Wickes. San Antonio newsboys need supervision. Here are three brothers — Sasser family, 729 Porter Street. The youngest one is five years old and makes 30 cents a day. Lawrence is seven years old but "he spends all he earns" his brother says. Boyce[?], makes 75 cents a day, and has a hard time keeping the others at work. Boyce is ten years old. They all start out at 6:00 A.M. and sell until 9:00 and 10:00 P.M. nearly every day except Sunday. I found them selling after ten P.M. Boyce said "We don't go to school; got to sell papers. Father is sick." Location: San Antonio, Texas. 1913. Photograph. Library of Congress Prints and Photographs Division. https://www.loc.gov/item/2018673940/.

Source Type
Photographs and Prints
Suggested Grade Band: Grade 3, Grade 4, Grade 5
Describe How Students Will Engage with the Source

Students will review the circumstances leading up to the Progressive Era, including the discontent surrounding child labor laws. They will look closely at the picture of the Sasser family and infer what their life might be like using visual clues from the image. After comparing the life of the Sasser boys to their own, students will create a side-by-side image comparing the life of a child laborer in the early 1900s to their own lives today.

Historical/Community Context for the Primary Source

Child labor was common in the United States until the late 1930s, with a reported 75,000 children under the age of 15 working in the 1870s. Many of these jobs were labor intensive, and some were dangerous. Oftentimes, children who had to work to help support their families were unable to attend school. Lewis Hine, the photographer, was an investigator for the National Child Labor Committee.

 

Source: https://www.britannica.com/video/did-you-know-child-labor-in-the-United-States/-258939

https://www.loc.gov/collections/national-child-labor-committee/articles-and-essays/reporting-on-labor-conditions/

 

Source: : https://www.britannica.com/video/did-you-know-child-labor-in-the-United-States/-258939

https://www.loc.gov/collections/national-child-labor-committee/articles-and-essays/reporting-on-labor-conditions/

 

Instructional Focus Question(s) for Discussion
  1. How does the photographer’s purpose influence his work as evidenced in “San Antonio Newsboys Need Supervision”?
    1. What story is he telling through the image?
    2. Who is his audience?
    3. Does it achieve the intended goal? Is it impactful?
  2. Based on what we’ve learned from this image, how do images enhance or detract from facts and information in photojournalism and investigative reporting today, and what influence do they have on society as a whole? How does the addition of AI affect things?
Standards Connection (State)
TX
Standards Connections

Texas

 

ELA Standards

7.6.G. Response skills. Discuss and write about the explicit or implicit meanings of text.

Social Studies Standards

7.7.C. History. Describe and compare the impact of reform movements in Texas in the 19th and 20th centuries such as progressivism, populism, women’s suffrage, agrarianism, labor reform, and the conservative movement of the late 20th century.

NCTE Standard 12

Students use spoken, written, and visual language to accomplish their own purposes (e.g., for learning, enjoyment, persuasion, and the exchange of information).

Instructional Design
  • Show students the image of the Sasser family and ask them to observe what they are seeing without any other context. Invite students to share their observations without making any kind of inferences.
  • Continue showing the image and ask students to reflect on the story the image is showing. Have them freewrite their ideas.
  • Allow students to share their thoughts and discuss how these observations and reflections change or enhance their own thoughts and questions about the image.
  • Share that the image was taken by an investigative reporter in the early 1900s. Ask them to write a caption for the image.
  • Next, share the actual image caption and information about the photographer, Lewis Hine.
    • Considering his line of work, do you think this changed how the pictures were composed by Mr. Hine?
    • Does it impact the way you receive the information?
    • Is your opinion influenced based on where information you see today is sourced? Does it change based on who the author/photographer is?
  • Regardless of audience or intent, remind students that child labor was common during this time in history and school attendance was not required. Have students create a side-by-side drawing showing children in the early 1900s versus children now. They can present it as two “photos” next to each other, a side-by-side comic, or even a meme (“How it started/How it’s going”).

Students should include a short written reflection with their drawings.

Tags:
Drawing, Freewrite, Image analysis, Primary source analysis, Visual literacy
Alternative or Complementary Primary Sources

Hine, Lewis Wickes. Lionel Perry, nine year old newsboy. Starts out at 5:00 A.M. usually. 4:00 A.M. on Sundays. Sells after school. Location: San Antonio, Texas. 1913. Photograph. Library of Congress Prints and Photographs Division. https://www.loc.gov/item/2018673933/.

Subject/Topic:
Journalism/news, advertising, Photography
Is Mosaic Content
On

Entrance Sign to Hemisfair Park

Entrance Sign to Hemisfair Park
Lesson By
Katrina Simmons
Citation

Highsmith, Carol M. Entrance sign to Hemisfair Park in downtown San Antonio, Texas. 2014. Photograph. Library of Congress Prints and Photographs Division. https://www.loc.gov/item/2014632003/.

Source Type
Photographs and Prints
Suggested Grade Band: Grade 6, Grade 7, Grade 8
Describe How Students Will Engage with the Source

Students will look at the image of the “Entrance to Hemisfair Park,” connecting it to any experiences they might have with the area. Then, they will learn about the history of the park and how it was built as part of the 1968 World’s Fair. Once discussing the changes that happened in the downtown landscape at the time in order to create the area, students will learn about current proposals being made to update and change the Hemisfair area again. After reading about the current proposals, students will decide whether or not they think the changes are a benefit to the city, and they will craft a letter to the city council laying out their opinion.

Historical/Community Context for the Primary Source

Hemisfair Park was constructed for the 1968 World’s Fair held in downtown San Antonio, Texas. The event was also a celebration for the 250th anniversary of the city’s founding. In preparation for the occasion, many San Antonio landmarks were added to the city, including the Convention Center, an extension of the Riverwalk, and the Tower of the Americas. Although the development of the area did much to move the city forward, many families were displaced in the process. The redevelopment of the area continues to evolve, most recently with a proposal to turn it into a sports and entertainment district.

 

Source: https://www.tshaonline.org/handbook/entries/hemisfair-68

https://www.sa.gov/Directory/Initiatives/Sports-Entertainment-District

 

Source: : https://www.tshaonline.org/handbook/entries/hemisfair-68

https://www.sa.gov/Directory/Initiatives/Sports-Entertainment-District

 

Instructional Focus Question(s) for Discussion
  1. Looking at the “Entrance Sign to Hemisfair Park,” what does the sign evoke from the original ’68 World’s Fair? What does the sign seem to symbolize today?
  2. Should Hemisfair Park remain a central focus to downtown San Antonio, and if so, what form should it take?
Standards Connection (State)
TX
Standards Connections

Texas

 

ELA Standards

7.11.D.Composition. Compose correspondence that reflects an opinion, registers a complaint, or requests information in a business or friendly structure.

Social Studies Standard

7.20.E. Social studies skills. The student applies critical-thinking skills to organize and use information acquired through established research methodologies from a variety of valid sources, including technology. The student is expected to formulate and communicate visually, orally, or in writing a claim supported by evidence and reasoning related to a social studies topic.

NCTE Standard 7

Students conduct research on issues and interests by generating ideas and questions, and by posing problems. They gather, evaluate, and synthesize data from a variety of sources (e.g., print and nonprint texts, artifacts, people) to communicate their discoveries in ways that suit their purpose and audience.

Instructional Design
  • Show the image of the “Entrance Sign to Hemisfair Park” to students. Have students observe the image. Ask them what they know about the place in the picture. Some students may have prior knowledge connected to the location while others will use details in the picture to construct their responses.
  • Share the history of Hemisfair Park with the students, letting them know it was built for the 1968 World’s Fair and in conjunction with the 250th anniversary of San Antonio’s foundation as a city. Students can get a taste of what the fair was like with videos from the Texas Archive of Moving Images like https://youtu.be/IXffcEvBKr0. There is also a website curated by Christopher Medina that explores many aspects of the fair accompanied with photos and memorabilia here: https://worldsfair68.info/
  • Ask students how they think the visitors from around the world felt going to the fair. What about local community members?
  • Share with them that while many improvements were made to the area in preparation for the fair (some of which still endure today), many families and businesses were displaced to make room for new buildings and businesses. How might this change the way some community members perceive the fair?
  • After sharing the history of the Hemisfair area, talk to students about what is currently happening with the park. It has been over 50 years since the ’68 World’s Fair, and currently, there is a redevelopment plan in place, working to bring businesses and more housing. The city is also considering turning the area into a sports and entertainment district.
  • Have students research the upcoming proposal at https://www.sa.gov/Directory/Initiatives/Sports-Entertainment-District. List pros and cons of the changes as they are reading about the plan. Students should consider the information and decide whether they approve of the proposed changes or whether they think the area should remain the way it is. They will write a letter to the council, sharing their opinion and using evidence from their research to support their reasoning. Remind them to think of all the stakeholders when crafting their letter and also to consider how the choices the city of San Antonio makes now will have an effect on generations of San Antonioians now and in the future.
Tags:
Authentic voice, Opinion writing, Primary source analysis, Research, Visual literacy
Alternative or Complementary Primary Sources

Highsmith, Carol M. A barge loaded with visitors plies a portion of the San Antonio River that winds through San Antonio's lively, underground River Walk, which turned an unsightly slum into an international tourist attraction. Looming in the distance on the streets above is the Tower of the Americas, the theme structure of the "HemisFair" World's Fair. 2014. Photograph. Library of Congress Prints and Photographs Division. https://www.loc.gov/item/2014633883/.

Subject/Topic:
Art and architecture , Geography, history, social studies
Is Mosaic Content
On

The San Antonio Fact Book

The San Antonio Fact Book
Lesson By
Katrina Simmons
Citation

The San Antonio fact book ... a book for every tourist, every homeseeker, every official, every business man, every teacher, every student, every resident of Texas and San Antonio. San Antonio: The Smile Book Co., 1915. https://www.loc.gov/item/15016605/.

Source Type
Books and Other Printed Texts Manuscripts
Suggested Grade Band: Kindergarten, Grade 1, Grade 2
Describe How Students Will Engage with the Source

Students will observe the cover page and listen to selected facts contained in The San Antonio Fact Book. Then, they will compare it with more modern city or state travel guides. As a group, they will create their own guidebooks for their school, city, or state.

Historical/Community Context for the Primary Source

San Antonio is a city that has grown and evolved over time. The San Antonio Fact Book, originally published in 1915, documents facts the author felt were important and unique to the city at the time. While the square footage and numbers of people, businesses, schools, etc., have changed, the city has grown proportionally to maintain a similar relationship to the other cities and towns in the state that it had over 100 years ago. Many of the historical facts remain the same, even if the way they are perceived is not exactly the same.

Source: https://www.britannica.com/place/San-Antonio-Texas

 

Source: : https://www.britannica.com/place/San-Antonio-Texas

 

Instructional Focus Question(s) for Discussion
  1. How do you think the author of The San Antonio Fact Book chose which items to include for others to learn?
    1. Who is his audience?
    2. Did he leave out anything important?
    3. Do you think his viewpoint is completely factual?
  2. What things does the author of The San Antonio Fact Book thinks are important for someone to know about the city? Do you agree or disagree? Why?
Standards Connection (State)
TX
Standards Connections

Texas

 

ELA Standard

2.12B. Composition. Compose informational texts, including procedural texts and reports.

Social Studies Standard

2.1B. History. Identify and explain the significance of various community, state, and national landmarks such as monuments and government buildings.

NCTE Standard 4

Students adjust their use of spoken, written, and visual language (e.g., conventions, style, vocabulary) to communicate effectively with a variety of audiences and for different purposes.

Instructional Design
  • Students will take a close look at the cover page of The San Antonio Fact Book (image 1). Guide students to observe the page and discuss. Things to consider include:
    • When was this book created?
    • What kind of information do you think will be in this book?
    • What do you think the author’s purpose is?
  • Next, share some of the facts found in the book and discuss why someone might want to know this information.
  • Read a children’s picture book version of a city or state fact book (i.e., This Is series by M. Sasek or Larry Gets Lost series by John Skewes).
  • Have students compare the modern-day book to The San Antonio Fact Book. Focus on similarities and differences in what is shared and how it is shared.
  • Discuss what kind of things students think should be in a fact book and make a list on the board.
  • In groups of 3–4, students will create a fact book about their city or state.
  • Once completed, books can be displayed in the classroom or school library.
Tags:
Compare and contrast, Informative writing, Primary source analysis, Small group, Visual literacy
Alternative or Complementary Primary Sources

Great San Antonio, the city of destiny and of your destination. San Antonio: Higher Publicity League of Texas, 1919. https://www.loc.gov/item/19003089/.

Subject/Topic:
American popular culture, Geography, history, social studies
Is Mosaic Content
On

La Antorcha de la Amistad

La Antorcha de la Amistad
Lesson By
Katrina Simmons
Citation

Highsmith, Carol M. La Antorcha de la Amistad (Spanish for "The Torch of Friendship"), a monumental abstract sculpture in downtown San Antonio, Texas. 2014. Photograph. Library of Congress Prints and Photographs Division. https://www.loc.gov/item/2014633120/.

Source Type
Art/Architecture
Suggested Grade Band: Kindergarten, Grade 1, Grade 2
Describe How Students Will Engage with the Source

After listening to a picturebook, students will be guided to look closely at the sculpture in the picture and discuss what it makes them think of. Once their ideas are shared, the teacher will tell the students the name of the sculpture and discuss if that changes or enhances their understanding of what the artist created. They will be invited to create their own drawing or sculpture that symbolizes an abstract feeling or idea. Students will write or give an oral description of their artwork.

Historical/Community Context for the Primary Source

Located at the heart of San Antonio, La Antorcha de Amistad, or The Torch of Friendship, is a sculpture by Mexican artist Sebastian. It was gifted to the city by a group of Mexican entrepreneurs in 2002 to symbolize the strong ties between San Antonio and Mexico.

Source: https://events.getcreativesanantonio.com/public-art/torch-of-friendship-antorcha-de-amistad/

 

Source: : https://events.getcreativesanantonio.com/public-art/torch-of-friendship-antorcha-de-amistad/

 

Instructional Focus Question(s) for Discussion
  1. How does the sculpture La Antorcha de Amistad symbolize San Antonio’s relationship with Mexico?
    1. What do characteristics like the size, color, and placement of the sculpture lead the viewer to think about the artist’s creation?
  2. How does looking at this sculpture help us better understand the relationship between Mexico and San Antonio? How can looking at art, particularly abstract art, help us understand our relationship to the world around us?
Standards Connection (State)
TX
Standards Connections

Texas

 

ELA Standard

2.7.E. Response skills. Interact with sources in meaningful ways such as illustrating or writing.

Social Studies Standard

2.11. Citizenship. The student understands important symbols, customs, and celebrations that represent American beliefs and principles that contribute to our national identity.

NCTE Standard 2

Students read a wide range of literature from many periods in many genres to build an understanding of the many dimensions (e.g., philosophical, ethical, aesthetic) of human experience.

Instructional Design
  • Students will listen to the story Invisible Things by Andy J. Pizza and Sophie Miller. While reading, take a closer look at some of the “invisible things” and have students discuss how the shapes, colors, and characteristics the illustrators used are connected to the feelings or ideas they are supposed to represent.
  • Brainstorm with students other feelings or ideas in the world that we cannot see.
  • Explain that San Antonio has a sculpture that could very easily be included in the Invisible Things book. Without sharing the name of the sculpture, have students take a close look at La Antorcha de Amistad. Discuss the features of the sculpture. Guiding questions could include:
    • How does the color make you feel? What do you think it might symbolize?
    • What do you think the size or the placement of the sculpture might mean?
    • Do you think the shape represents something?
  • After giving students the chance to give their own interpretations, share with them the history of the sculpture and why it was gifted to San Antonio.
    • Does knowing the history and name of the sculpture change what you think it symbolizes? How or how not?
  • Using the brainstorming list from earlier, have students choose their own feeling or idea and create a drawing or clay sculpture to represent it. They can name their artwork and write and/or orally present to the class a short description about what their piece represents.
Tags:
Art analysis, Brainstorming, Descriptive/reflective writing, Drawing, Primary source analysis, Symbolism, Visual literacy
Alternative or Complementary Primary Sources

Highsmith, Carol M. The sculpture "Companion (Passing Through)," by the artist KAWS (Brian Donnelly) at the Modern Art Museum of Fort Worth, Texas. 2012. Photograph. Library of Congress Prints and Photographs Division. https://www.loc.gov/item/2013650780/.

Subject/Topic:
Art and architecture , Photography
Is Mosaic Content
On

Mexican girls, San Antonio, Tex.

Mexican girls, San Antonio, Tex.
Lesson By
Katrina Simmons
Citation

Lomax, Alan. Mexican girls, San Antonio, Tex. 1934. Photograph. Library of Congress Prints and Photographs Division. https://www.loc.gov/item/2007660003/.

Source Type
Photographs and Prints
Suggested Grade Band: Kindergarten, Grade 1, Grade 2
Describe How Students Will Engage with the Source

Students will look at the image of the girls and will observe, with guidance, what they are doing. They will discuss the importance of music in their own lives and talk about what some of their favorite songs are. Students will then choose a song they want to preserve for history and make a recording of the song by themselves or with a group. In their recording, they will explain why this song or rhyme means something to them.

Historical/Community Context for the Primary Source

Alan Lomax was an ethnomusicologist known for traveling the country and recording people of various ages and demographics singing folk songs. In addition to audio recordings, he documented his sessions with photographs of the people he recorded.

Source: https://www.britannica.com/biography/Alan-Lomax

 

Source: : https://www.britannica.com/biography/Alan-Lomax

 

Instructional Focus Question(s) for Discussion
  1. What do you think the girls in the photograph are doing? How do you think the girls in the photo feel about being able to record a song that is important to them? How do you know?
    1. Is music an important part of our history?
    2. How does music make you feel?
    3. Does different music change the way you feel?
    4. What music would you share if someone wanted to record you today?
Standards Connection (State)
TX
Standards Connections

Texas

 

ELA Standard

K.1. Developing and sustaining foundational language skills. Listening, speaking, discussion, and thinking—oral language. The student develops oral language through listening, speaking, and discussion.

Social Studies Standard

K.14.C. Social studies skills. Communicate information visually, orally, or in writing based on knowledge and experiences in social studies.

NCTE Standard 12

Students use spoken, written, and visual language to accomplish their own purposes (e.g., for learning, enjoyment, persuasion, and the exchange of information).

Instructional Design
  • Students will look at the image of the girls gathered around the microphone. Have them discuss what they see, prompting them to keep observing and noting things. If students need guidance, ask them:
    • Where do you think they are?
    • What does it look like they are doing?
    • What time of year is it?
    • How are they dressed?
    • How do you think they feel?
  • Play an Alan Lomax recording of children singing. (There are multiple options, but it is quite possible that the recording of “Hijo, hijo, mira esta mujer” is a recording of the girls in the picture.) Explain that back before people had phones and computers to record things whenever they wanted, Alan Lomax took his special recording device around the country to collect songs and stories that were important to people. He thought this was an important part of our history, and it was something he thought we should keep.
  • Have students think about different places they might sing or chant rhymes (i.e., school, home, in the car, on the playground, church). Have students share some of the songs and rhymes that they enjoy and think are important.
  • Tell students to think like a historian and try to choose one song they would like to save for the future. Using an iPad or Chromebook, allow the students to record their song (or a piece of their song) alone or in a group. At the beginning or end of the recording, have the students share what it is about their song that is important to them—maybe they have a strong memory tied to it, or maybe it is a song that everybody knows.
  • Set up the songs at a listening center for students to hear.
Tags:
Primary source analysis, Singing, Speaking, Visual literacy
Alternative or Complementary Primary Sources

Gonzales, Josephine, Aurora Gonzales, Pearl Manchaco, Adela Flores, Lia Trujillo, Alan Lomax, and John A. Lomax. Hijo, hijo, mira esta muher. Recorded 1934. Audio recording. https://www.loc.gov/item/ihas.200196320/.

Subject/Topic:
Music, recorded sound, performing arts, Photographs, prints, posters
Is Mosaic Content
On

Marble statue of Stephen F. Austin

Marble statue of Stephen F. Austin
Lesson By
Katrina Simmons
Citation

Highsmith, Carol M. Marble statue of Stephen F. Austin, by Elizabet Ney, unveiled on this spot in the Texas Capitol South Foyer in 1903. Austin, Texas. 2014. Photograph. Library of Congress Prints and Photographs Division. https://www.loc.gov/item/2014632127/.

Source Type
Photographs and Prints
Suggested Grade Band: Grade 3, Grade 4, Grade 5
Describe How Students Will Engage with the Source

After learning about Stephen F. Austin and his contributions to the founding of Texas as a republic and state, students will take a close look at the statue of Stephen F. Austin. They will discuss how his contributions to the state are conveyed in the statue representing him and whether or not they feel it is an accurate representation. Then, they will learn about the significance of where the statue is located and decide who else might be able to exemplify Texas beliefs and values.

Historical/Community Context for the Primary Source

Beginning in 1864, a law was enacted to allow each state to contribute two statues of notable people from their state to the National Statuary Hall in the United States Capitol. While the statues are now dispersed throughout the Capitol, each state has two statues representing them. The statues for Texas are Stephen F. Austin and Sam Houston.

Source: https://www.britannica.com/topic/Statuary-Hall

 

Source: : https://www.britannica.com/topic/Statuary-Hall

 

Instructional Focus Question(s) for Discussion
  1. Considering both the construction and the materials it is made out of, what does the statue of Stephen F. Austin symbolize?
  2. What does it say about the beliefs and values of the state of Texas when it chose Stephen F. Austin to memorialize and represent the state?
Standards Connection (State)
TX
Standards Connections

Texas

 

ELA Standard

4.12.C. Composition. Compose argumentative texts, including opinion essays, using genre characteristics and craft.

Social Studies Standard

4.19.A .Social studies skills. Differentiate between, locate, and use valid primary and secondary sources such as technology; interviews; biographies; oral, print, and visual material; documents; and artifacts to acquire information about Texas.

NCTE Standards 7

Students conduct research on issues and interests by generating ideas and questions, and by posing problems. They gather, evaluate, and synthesize data from a variety of sources (e.g., print and nonprint texts, artifacts, people) to communicate their discoveries in ways that suit their purpose and audience.

Instructional Design
  • Students will engage in a quickwrite of the things they remember about Stephen F. Austin.
  • After students have an opportunity to share with one another, display the image of Stephen F. Austin’s statue. As a class, discuss ways in which the statue reflects what they know about Austin’s contributions to history and the state.
  • Ask students to consider the following:
    • What do the things Austin is wearing and holding represent or say about him?
    • Is there a significance to his stance or where he is looking?
  • Once students have discussed the statue and what it symbolizes, tell them about the National Statuary Hall Collection in the United States Capitol.
  • In small groups, let students explore the statues for other states and make a list of key things they notice. (https://www.visitthecapitol.gov/apps/nshc/) Have students discuss the following:
    • Why do we erect statues and monuments of people and events from our past?
      • What do these people/events have in common?
      • How are they different?
      • Is anyone being left out?
    • Does the statue of Austin adequately represent his contributions to Texas?
    • How do the subjects chosen for other states compare and contrast to those chosen in Texas?
  • Once students have gathered ideas on what characteristics are required to be included in the National Statuary Hall Collection, have them brainstorm other notable Texans who might be worthy of selection.
  • Using their discussions as inspiration, have each student choose someone in Texas history they think adequately represents the state. Have students research their chosen subject to collect evidence they will use to support their choice.
  • Using their research, students will write a letter to Congress laying out their case for why they think their person should be memorialized and added to the collection.
  • Have students create a sketch or clay model of how the statue should look. Display letters and representations in a gallery for classmates to view. Letters can also be mailed to Congressional representatives.
Tags:
Letter writing, Quickwrite, Primary source analysis, Research, Small group, Visual literacy
Alternative or Complementary Primary Sources

Highsmith, Carol M. Marble statue of Sam Houston by Elizabet Ney, unveiled on this spot in the Texas Capitol South Foyer in 1903. Austin, Texas. 2014. Photograph. Library of Congress Prints and Photographs Division. https://www.loc.gov/item/2014632128/.

Subject/Topic:
Art and architecture , Geography, history, social studies
Is Mosaic Content
On

Galveston, 1900

Galveston, 1900
Lesson By
Kelly E. Tumy
Citation

Galveston 1900. 1900. Photograph. Library of Congress Prints and Photographs Division. https://www.loc.gov/item/2014699678/.

Source Type
Photographs and Prints
Suggested Grade Band: Grade 3, Grade 4, Grade 5
Describe How Students Will Engage with the Source

Before beginning a lesson on the geographic and economic impact of hurricanes, ask students where in Texas this picture could have been taken. Then, ask students what kind of situation they are reminded of when they look at this. Students who live in coastal areas should be able to identify the situation (hurricane or tornado). In many regions of Texas, students would have some association with bad weather events.

Historical/Community Context for the Primary Source

In 1900, a tropical cyclone (hurricane) hit Galveston, Texas. At the time it struck the Gulf Coast, Galveston was on track to become the economic epicenter of both Texas and the Gulf.

Source: https://www.britannica.com/event/Galveston-hurricane-of-1900

Instructional Focus Question(s) for Discussion
  1. How can destruction like this affect the economy of a coastal town?
  2. How does a hurricane affect families?
  3. How does a hurricane affect businesses?
  4. What do you think it takes to rebuild a city after a destructive weather event?
  5. What do you think happened to Galveston after this event?
  6. How can communities prepare better for weather events in today’s society?
Standards Connection (State)
TX
Standards Connections

Texas

ELA Standard

4.7(A). Describe personal connections to a variety of sources, including self-selected texts

Social Studies Standard

4.6(B). Compare the physical regions of Texas (Mountains and Basins, Great Plains, North Central Plains, Coastal Plains).

NCTE Standard 5

Students employ a wide range of strategies as they write and use different writing process elements appropriately to communicate with different audiences for a variety of purposes.

Instructional Design
  • After the instructional questions, pass out maps of different regions of Texas: Mountains and Basins, Great Plains, North Central Plains, and Coastal Plains) and discuss the different weather experienced in all regions.
  • Have students use resources to add the primary type of economy of each region in 1900.
  • Have students create a chart about weather in the different regions of Texas.
  • Have students write a quick response to the following: How do you know this photograph was from the Coastal Plains? Use evidence from the photograph to support your response.
  • Create three separate groups to work on different complementary aspects of this piece of Texas history. Have students present their findings.
    • The American Society of Civil Engineers has a descriptive page about how the seawall was constructed after the 1900 hurricane. After reading that page, what can students tell a partner about the seawall, the economy of Galveston, and the social structure of Galveston?
    • The Galveston and Texas History Center also has information. After skimming both pages, ask students to explain how the two sites differ. Use a Venn diagram to show both similarities and differences. This site also has more primary sources. How are they similar to/different from the Library of Congress photograph?
    • Texas Parks and Wildlife also has a short video about how the wall was constructed.
Tags:
Group work, Primary source analysis, Reading maps, Venn diagram, Visual literacy, Writing assignment
Alternative or Complementary Primary Sources

Galveston 1900 — 18th and N Sts. 1900. Photograph. Library of Congress Prints and Photographs Division. https://www.loc.gov/item/2014699675/.

Subject/Topic:
Geography, history, social studies, Journalism/news, advertising
Is Mosaic Content
On

Pagination

  • First page « First
  • Previous page ‹‹
  • …
  • Page 86
  • Page 87
  • Page 88
  • Page 89
  • Page 90
  • Page 91
  • Page 92
  • Page 93
  • Page 94
  • Next page ››
  • Last page Last »

Explore Resources by Grade

  • KindergartenK
  • 1-2
  • 3-4
  • 5-6
  • 7-8
  • 9-10
  • 11-12

RWT-logo

Powered By NCTE

Footer 1 Menu

  • About
  • Classroom Resources
  • Professional Development
  • Collections
  • Contact Us

Footer 2 Menu

  • National Council of Teachers of English
  • Contribute to RWT
  • FAQs
  • Join NCTE

Footer 3 Menu

  • Legal Notices
  • Privacy Policy
  • Promotional Materials
  • Site Demonstrations

Want to stay in touch with RWT and NCTE? Sign up here!

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram
  • Pinterest
  • YouTube

© NCTE 2025. All rights reserved